Will inkjet replace web offset

# Will inkjet replace web offset No, not as a slogan, and not as a property of the machines. Ask what the product is, and how long the order is, and the answer splits. Publication work, catalogues, and some packaging each contain orders inkjet can take and orders web offset still fits. Inkjet takes a

Will inkjet replace web offset

No, not as a slogan, and not as a property of the machines. Ask what the product is, and how long the order is, and the answer splits. Publication work, catalogues, and some packaging each contain orders inkjet can take and orders web offset still fits. Inkjet takes a slice. Web offset keeps the long ones. Replacement would mean the long ones leave. They don't leave while they stay long.

A web press, either process, is a reel of paper moving through a machine that has to deliver a product, not a sheet you can admire and then decide about. The difference that matters isn't a mood about old and new. It's what each process has to do at the start of an order, and what it has to do when the order is one form for a long time.

Length is the question the slogan skips

Web offset earns its keep by diluting a start. Plates, webbing up, a colour OK, the waste that comes before good copies, and then the run. Heatset work adds a dryer that has to be in a steady state. Coldset work depends on the paper taking the ink without that dryer, which is its own bargain with show-through and with the folder. Once the press is running a single form, further copies are what the machine is for. A version change is not a small edit. It's a stop, different plates, and another start. The longer and more stable the order, the more that logic is the right one. Shorten the order, or multiply the forms, and the starts become the week.

Inkjet on a web takes the plates out of that story. A change of pages, of a regional section, or of a version can be a change of file rather than a change of metal. That is a real difference, and it's the difference buyers mean when they ask whether the offset web is finished. It isn't the whole machine. The ink is wet. Water has to leave the paper, or go into it, before the ribbon is fit to fold, cut, or rewind. Light publication paper cockles, grows, and lets ink strike through in ways a plant used to offset ink will not predict from a brochure. Drying has to be enough for the folder and not so fierce that the paper arrives brittle, wavy, or the wrong size for the binding. The press can image a changing form. It still has to deliver a product with a geometry.

So the hinge is the order, not the hardware generation. Below the length where plates, start-up waste, and a stop for every version get absorbed, inkjet is a serious candidate, provided the paper and the fold will cooperate. Above that length, with one stable form, inkjet has to win on something other than the absence of plates. Often it doesn't, because the absence of plates was the main thing it brought, and a long single form doesn't need that thing. Nobody has to pretend there's a universal length where this flips. The length lives in your order book: how many forms, how stable, what paper, what product comes off the end.

Publication

A publication that's still one edition, and still long enough that the start is a small part of the week, stays a web offset argument. The folder already delivers signatures. The paper is specified. The binding line, or the newspaper path, is built around that press. Moving it because inkjet exists would mean re-solving paper, drying, and the fold in order to obtain a benefit, no plates, that this particular order barely uses. That's a poor trade. The press isn't kept out of sentiment. It's kept because the order is still the order it was built for.

The publication work that moves, or that at least gets a hearing, is the work that stopped being one long form. Regional sections that used to be a compromise inside a single run. Editions that split. Titles whose frequency or whose pagination no longer fills the offset web with one stable product. A section that's different in every copy, or in every small batch, while the rest of the issue is common. In those cases the offset start is being spent on difference, which is exactly what a plate process charges you for. Inkjet is then a candidate for the part that's different, or for the whole issue if the whole issue has become short and various. It isn't a candidate because someone declared print "digital". It's a candidate because the form multiplied or the run shrank for reasons that belong to the publisher, not to the press manufacturer.

Paper still gets a vote. Uncoated publication stock, especially lighter stock and stock with a lot of mechanical fibre, was chosen for offset coldset or heatset, not for a water-based ink that has to dry in line. A plant that moves the work and then discovers cockle, growth, or a duller colour on the same grade hasn't been betrayed by a slogan. It skipped the mechanism. The inkjet web has to be tried on the paper the job actually uses, through the folder the product actually needs, before anyone talks about replacement. A good signature on a coated test reel doesn't answer a newspaper or a magazine that lives on a different sheet.

Catalogues

Catalogues split along the same hinge, and the split is easier to see because the product is so obviously either one book or many books wearing one brand.

One national catalogue, one version, a long run, a known paper, a bindery that expects that format: web offset. The pages don't change per recipient. The cover doesn't change per store cluster. There is nothing for a plateless press to save except the plates of a single form, and a single long form is the case offset is good at. A buyer who asks you to "put the catalogue on inkjet" without the versions changing is asking you to swap processes for a job that doesn't use the swap.

The catalogue that became many catalogues is a different object. Store clusters with different covers and different ranges. Language versions. A common body with a personalised section, or a section that changes by region while the rest holds still. Here the offset plant is either gang-running things that don't want to share a date, or starting the press repeatedly for forms that are mostly alike. That's the slice. Inkjet takes the versioned covers, the versioned sections, or the short editions. It doesn't automatically take the long static body if that body is still long and still one form. A sensible production scheme can even divide the book: the stable pages where length pays, the changing pages where a file change pays. That isn't a victory lap for either process. It's an admission that a catalogue stopped being one product.

Personalisation is the clearest case, and it's also the easiest to overclaim. A few changing lines on a cover aren't a reason to image the entire page count on a different process if the inside is a long common form. They're a reason to look at where the change sits and how the changed piece meets the rest at the bindery. The file being easy to vary doesn't make the unchanged pages short. Length still belongs to the pages that don't vary. If you image everything, varying and stable, on the inkjet web, you should be doing it because the whole run is short or because the binding of two streams costs more than imaging the stable pages a second way. That's a plant calculation. It isn't a law that catalogues have moved.

Some packaging, not packaging as such

Web offset also prints packaging: some flexible work, some board, long runs of a single design. The same hinge applies, with extra conditions that publication paper doesn't have. Heavy ink lay. Spot colours that are mixed inks, not a process build. A converting line, laminating, slitting, die-cutting, whose pace was set with the press as part of one route. A design that has to be the same colour in month six as in month one because the packs share a shelf.

Where that order is long and stable, web offset keeps it. The start is absorbed. The ink lay is what the process is used to. The converting steps aren't waiting on a drying experiment. Inkjet gets a hearing when the packaging order becomes a set of versions, or becomes too short for the offset start to make sense, and when the substrate will take the ink and still convert. That's a slice of packaging webs, not the category. A long single SKU with a heavy lay and a line already timed around the offset press doesn't become an inkjet job because a shorter SKU somewhere else did.

Direct mail and similar reel products sit nearer the catalogue case than the packaging case. One static mailing, long, is an offset web product. A mailing whose content changes through the run is the plateless argument, and even then the paper, the dry, and the finishing have to agree. Calling all of it "inkjet now" ignores the static long runs that never needed a different page in each envelope.

A slice, and the long ones

Answer the question in the order book, product by product. A long single-edition publication stays. A publication that has broken into editions and short forms is where inkjet is actually asked. A single national catalogue stays. A catalogue that became many versions gives inkjet the versions, and may keep the long common pages where they are. Long, stable packaging webs stay. Short and versioned packaging is the conversation, if the material and the converting will stand it.

Nothing in that list requires a claim about whose machine is faster, or about what portion of all print the change represents. Those claims are how the slogan sneaks back in. The mechanism is duller and more useful. Web offset is a length process. It keeps the orders that are still long and still one form, because that's the situation in which plates and a start are worth paying. Inkjet takes orders whose length, or whose number of forms, makes the start the dominant event, and whose paper and finishing can live with wet ink and in-line drying. When a long order becomes short because the buyer changed the product, you reassess that order. You don't reassess every long order in the building. The long ones haven't been replaced. They're still long.

Written by

Priya Shah

Prepress

Makes plates and proofs, and sends the file back when the press cannot fix it.

Related articles

Process

Flexo still fits packaging

# Flexo still fits packaging The buyer had been to a presentation, and he arrived wanting the range moved. Film, board, a family of labels, all of it, onto a di...

Process

Print on demand moves the stock and the cost

# Print on demand moves the stock and the cost The publisher showed me an empty bay and he was proud of it. A year ago the bay had held a title that sold steadi...

Process

Versioned packaging is a production problem

# Versioned packaging is a production problem Marketing called it a celebration. A commemorative sleeve, one brand, a dozen pictures, a few lines of type that c...

Process

Print that can be scanned, used and recovered

# Print that can be scanned, used and recovered The code scanned on the flat sheet. I watched the buyer's phone pick it up from the press table, quick and pleas...