Versioned packaging is a production problem

# Versioned packaging is a production problem Marketing called it a celebration. A commemorative sleeve, one brand, a dozen pictures, a few lines of type that changed with the retailer. On their deck it was personalisation, and the word was doing a lot of cheerful work. On our floor it was fourteen artworks, fourteen approvals,

Versioned packaging is a production problem

Marketing called it a celebration. A commemorative sleeve, one brand, a dozen pictures, a few lines of type that changed with the retailer. On their deck it was personalisation, and the word was doing a lot of cheerful work. On our floor it was fourteen artworks, fourteen approvals, a choice between plates and clicks, and a cage in the warehouse where the versions look like each other until you read the small line and realise you have just shipped the wrong celebration. I don't begrudge them the campaign. I begrudge the habit of arriving with the campaign already sold, and with the production treated as a mood that will sort itself out if we care enough.

Plates or clicks, the change still costs

Each artwork is a change, and a change is paid for in one of two currencies. On the flexo or litho press that already runs this sleeve, a new artwork is a plate, a mount or a hang, a register, a colour match back to the brand, and a pile of material spent before the version is good. Fourteen of those is not fourteen small favours. It is fourteen starts, even when the starts are slick, and the slickness is something the crew has to buy with time you didn't put on the deck. If the commemorative quantity of each picture is modest, the start can swallow the version. That is not a failure of attitude. It is arithmetic the plant does with material and hours, and it doesn't become kinder because the artwork is festive.

Digital takes the plate away and leaves the click, the stock, and the changeover of a different kind. A file can be next in the queue without a plate room. It cannot be next if the stock is different, if the finishing tool is different, or if the colour of version eight has to be argued back to version one after the engine has drifted. Personalisation that is truly a change of picture on the same blank, same size, same route, is the digital case I will defend. Personalisation that smuggles in a new substrate, a new varnish, and a new cut is fourteen jobs wearing one campaign's hat. Marketing hears "digital" and thinks the hat was enough. The planner hears fourteen routings.

We choose the currency per version, and we say so before anyone promises a single unit cost for "the sleeve." A hero picture with a long quantity can live on the conventional press and carry its plate. A retailer line with a tiny quantity and a late legal change can live on digital, if the blank is genuinely the same. Mixing them in one sentence, "just versions," is how the estimate becomes a fiction and the factory becomes late. I will print both. I won't pretend they are the same action because they share a brand colour.

Approvals multiply more quietly than the pictures

The pictures are the noisy part. The approvals are the part that actually stops the press. Each version has a legal line, a retailer mark, sometimes a language, sometimes a claim about the product that legal will not let us standardise. The brand signs the hero. Nobody wants to sign retailer seven, because retailer seven is "the same, basically," until it isn't. We have stood with a crew and a press in colour, waiting on a PDF that was "with their marketing," while the version in front of us was already different from the PDF by one line of small type. Basically is not a sign-off.

A version without a named approver is a version we should not have accepted. That sounds stern and it saves the campaign. We ask, at the start, who may say yes to each artwork, and what happens if that person is travelling when the proof is ready. A single brand manager who insists on seeing all fourteen in one sitting will hold the first four hostage to the last one, which the photographer hasn't delivered. A structure that lets the finished artworks move, and holds only the unfinished ones, needs to be agreed while everyone is still being polite. Agreed later, it feels like the plant is being difficult. Agreed at the beginning, it is just the campaign's calendar told the truth.

Colour approval has its own trap on versions. The hero is signed at the press. Version nine arrives a week later and the expectation is that it matches a memory of the hero, on a different picture, perhaps on a different process. We keep a pass and we keep the stock, and we still tell them that a digital version of a flexo hero will be a cousin, not a twin, unless we have proved that cousin on this material before the campaign. Surprises at that point are expensive because the other thirteen are already in motion. The time to be honest about match is while the deck is still a deck.

The warehouse is where versions become a shipping fault

Print can be right and the job can still fail in the cage. Fourteen sleeves that share a size, a board, and a brand colour are fourteen ways to pick the wrong pallet at six in the morning. The difference lives in a small retailer mark and a picture you can't read from a forklift. I have watched a good minder run a perfect version and a tired warehouse send it to the wrong region, and I have watched the blame land on "print" because print is the word on the invoice. The production problem includes identity after the press, or it isn't a solution.

What works is dull. A version code large enough to see on the pallet label, the same code on the sleeve where the packer can check it, a location in the cage that isn't "somewhere on the left," and a ban on mixing versions on a pallet because the quantity was awkward. Barcodes help when someone scans them and don't help when the scanner is in a drawer. We have had more success with a plain code and a coloured ticket on the pallet, ugly and large, than with a system that assumed everyone would behave like a demonstration. The commemorative job got both, after the first wrong pallet, which went out and came back and taught the building more than my earlier memo had.

Leftover versions are the cost nobody puts on the celebration. A commemorative that doesn't sell through cannot be restickered into next month's ordinary sleeve, or not without a second process that has its own damage and its own approval. Those leftovers occupy space, they look like money, and they become waste on a date the brand chooses and the plant stores until then. We now ask, before we print the last version, what the unsold quantity is allowed to do. If the answer is "we'll decide later," we print closer to the quantity they will actually take, even if that feels less efficient on the press. A tidy unit cost on a sleeve that will be scrapped is a story for the deck, not for the cage.

Personalisation, as the plant hears it

I don't mind the word if we translate it. Sometimes the buyer means a name on a pack, truly variable, each one different, which is a data job and a digital job and a proofing problem of a new kind: you cannot show every name, so you agree the rules and you pull samples through the run. Sometimes the buyer means what this campaign was, a set of fixed artworks in modest quantities, which is versioning and should be planned as versioning. Sometimes the buyer means a language change for a market, with legal consequences, which is a new product that happens to share a dieline. Calling all three personalisation lets a meeting stay short and leaves the plant to discover the differences at plating.

The plant's side of the meeting is a right to split the word. How many distinct artworks. Which of them are late. Which quantities can carry a plate. Which must share a blank if they are going to be digital. Who signs. How the pallet is identified. What happens to the surplus. Those questions are the production problem stated as politely as I know how. A brand that can answer them can have a very lively set of versions, and we will be glad of the work. A brand that answers with the campaign name and a deadline can have a lecture, or a late job, or a wrong pallet. I have done all three. The lecture is the cheapest.

There is also the file itself, which multiplies errors as it multiplies artworks. One dieline, linked, with the pictures placed, and a naming scheme a stranger could follow at midnight, is a versioned job. Fourteen unique files, each "final," each named final_FINAL, with a legal line typed rather than placed, is a recollection waiting to happen. We send back the mess early, even when it makes us look unhelpful in the week the campaign is excited. Excitement doesn't register the small type. The press will.

What we did with the celebration

We split the fourteen. Four hero pictures, quantities that could carry plates, ran on the press that already knew the brand colour, with a pass signed on the first and used against the next three. Seven retailer versions, short, same blank, ran digital, each released when its own approver said yes, without waiting for the photographer who was still late. Three were held because the artwork wasn't actually finished, whatever the deck had implied, and they were printed in a later week rather than guessed. The warehouse tickets were large. The surplus rule was written down: leftovers of a retailer version would be offered once to that retailer and then recycled as print waste, not stored into the autumn "in case."

Marketing got their celebration. They also got a sheet from us that listed artworks, quantities, process, approver, and pallet code, and they liked it less than the deck. The brand manager told me it felt like we had turned a story into a factory. The sleeves on the shelf were the story. The factory was how the right sleeve got to the right shelf, with the right small line, without a second lorry of apologies. Versioned packaging can be good work and even good fun. It stops being either when the plant is asked to absorb the confusion and call the confusion a form of care. We can print many small artworks. We need them to be many small, finished, identified jobs. That is the whole demand. It is less romantic than personalisation, and it is the reason the right pack left the building.

Written by

Ruth Keller

Quality

Reads the sheet, the barcode and the proof, and says what she will not sign.

Related articles

Process

Flexo still fits packaging

# Flexo still fits packaging The buyer had been to a presentation, and he arrived wanting the range moved. Film, board, a family of labels, all of it, onto a di...

Process

Print on demand moves the stock and the cost

# Print on demand moves the stock and the cost The publisher showed me an empty bay and he was proud of it. A year ago the bay had held a title that sold steadi...

Process

Print that can be scanned, used and recovered

# Print that can be scanned, used and recovered The code scanned on the flat sheet. I watched the buyer's phone pick it up from the press table, quick and pleas...

Process

The energy argument around short-run digital

# The energy argument around short-run digital Sales had a slide with a pile of makeready sheets on one side and a tidy digital delivery on the other. The engin...