Print on demand moves the stock and the cost
# Print on demand moves the stock and the cost The publisher showed me an empty bay and he was proud of it. A year ago the bay had held a title that sold steadily and a title that didn't, and the second one had occupied the same rack, the same fire risk, and the
Print on demand moves the stock and the cost
The publisher showed me an empty bay and he was proud of it. A year ago the bay had held a title that sold steadily and a title that didn't, and the second one had occupied the same rack, the same fire risk, and the same argument with his finance director. Now the books are printed against sales. The bay is a bay. He talked as if the cost had left with the pallets. It hasn't left. It has changed address. His warehouse is smaller. Our unit cost is not the unit cost of the long run we used to print for him, and the rush that used to be his problem on a reprint is now our problem on a Tuesday. Somebody still pays. The useful conversation is about who, and for which part.
The stock moved, and the risk moved with it
What he got rid of is real, and I won't talk it down. Unsold books are a publisher's classic wound. They are printed in hope, stored in caution, and remaindered in regret. Printing against a sale, or against a short, honest forecast, shrinks that wound. Cash that used to sit in a pallet can sit somewhere else. The title that dies can die without a lorry of paper to pulp. A plant that prints books should be glad of this, because a customer who isn't buried in dead stock is a customer who can still order. I am glad of the empty bay. I am not glad of the sentence that treats the empty bay as a gift the printer somehow owes him.
The risk didn't evaporate. Some of it moved into our paper store. If we hold the sheet he likes, in case his sales tick up, we are holding the stock he used to hold, only earlier in the chain and cut to press size. If we don't hold it, the week his book is suddenly wanted is a week we are waiting on a merchant while he explains a delay to a shop. Both arrangements are legitimate. They are not the same price and they are not the same promise, and the contract ought to say which one we are in. A handshake that says "print on demand" and leaves the paper unspoken is a handshake that will be argued about in November, when every publisher's titles want to move at once.
Files moved as well, and files are a quieter stock. A print-ready book, covers and text, with the fonts behaved and the spine width honest, is an asset. Someone stores it, updates it when a reprint corrects a page, and keeps the old file from coming back to haunt the new one. If that someone is us, we are doing editorial-adjacent work he may still think of as his warehouse's old reprint, the one where you pulled a pallet and didn't ask questions. Questions are the work now. A corrected page that isn't in the file is a corrected page that will be wrong in every copy we make after the correction. We need the file owner named, the same way the old warehouse had a manager.
The unit cost did not shrink with the bay
A long run spreads the awkward parts. Making ready a text, whether on a litho press or a digital one, setting a binder, adjusting a cover, checking a spine, getting a jacket to sit: those actions exist for a thousand copies and they exist for one. On the thousand they hide inside the pile. On the one they are the pile. His empty bay was full of books whose unit cost had enjoyed that hiding. The new copies don't get to enjoy it. If I price them as if they were still a slice of the old run, I am paying for his empty bay out of my binder. I did that for a season, because the work was welcome and the logic took a while to become obvious. The season was enough.
Paper bought for ones and tens is not paper bought for a long run, even when the sheet is the same merchant's sheet. We buy smaller, or we cut from stock we are financing, and the waste from a short text doesn't vanish because the text is noble. Covers are worse. A cover likes a run. A single jacket, printed and laminated and brought to the case, carries its own set-up in a way a reader never sees and a publisher feels if we have the nerve to show him. I would rather show him. A unit cost that pretends a single case-bound book is a shy version of a thousand-copy unit cost will make both of us stupid. He will order as if the shyness were real. I will dread the orders I asked for.
There is also the copy we spoil. On a long run a spoiled copy is a percentage I am not going to invent and a problem the pile can absorb. On a run of one, the spoiled copy is the run. The binder does it again, and the "unit cost" has doubled in the only way that matters, by happening twice. Pricing and scheduling have to admit a second attempt without treating the operator as a scandal. Demand printing that only works when nobody makes a mistake is a poster. The work is allowed to be remade, and the remake has a home in the price or it has a home in my margin. I have chosen, after that season, to put it in the price.
The rush moved into our week
His warehouse used to be a shock absorber. A review, a shortlist, a shop display, a course reading list: the pallet was there, and the excitement didn't have to be manufactured. Now the excitement arrives as an email. He is right to send it. The title is selling, and the whole point of the empty bay was to be able to respond. The response uses the same binders, the same cover line, and the same people who are already inside a planned job for someone else. A rush is a queue being reordered. Reordering has a cost, and it is paid by someone: the job that was moved, the overtime, the paper that has to come from a more expensive door because the cheap door was tomorrow.
We can design for this. A defined capacity for short-notice titles, a cut-off, a rule about which promised jobs may be moved, and a frank word when the week is full. What we can't do is live as if every spike were a pleasant exception. November is not an exception. The start of a teaching year is not an exception. A prize list is not an exception once you print the kind of books that get prizes. If his business has a season, our price and our diary have to have the same season. Otherwise I am selling him a warehouse I don't have, made of my crew's evenings.
The rush also changes the service he notices. On the old model, a late reprint was a publishing embarrassment and the printer was one of several causes. On this model, the printer is the warehouse. A missed Tuesday is an empty shop. That is a higher duty than the old reprint, and it belongs in the contract beside the unit cost, not as a mood of wanting to be helpful. Helpful is how we got the season I am still paying for. A stated service, with a stated limit, is how he gets copies when it matters and how I still have a crew in December.
Who pays, if we say it properly
He pays for the absence of dead stock by paying a higher unit cost on the copies that do sell, and by paying for speed when the speed disturbs a plan. That is the fair shape. He has dropped the cost of the bay, the cost of remaindering, and the cost of guessing wrong on a print run. Those savings are his. They don't also entitle him to the old unit cost. If a quote of mine still carries the old unit cost out of habit, I am handing the savings back and keeping the rush. I have stopped writing that quote.
I pay if I hold paper for him without saying so, if I store and nurse his files without a fee or a duty written down, if I break my own promises to other customers so often that they leave, and if I price the work as a favour because I like the books. Some of those costs are easy to miss because they don't look like a line on his invoice. A rack of his sheet, a folder of his titles, a planner's hour spent reordering Tuesday: none of them feel like a product until the rack is full and Tuesday is a mess. Naming them is the point of the conversation. He is a good publisher. He can hear a named cost. He couldn't hear it when it was disguised as me being a partner.
There is a third payer who should stay visible. The reader, or the shop, pays if the copy simply costs more to produce and the price of the book moves. That is their transaction with him, not with me. I don't set his retail price and I don't apologise for the unit cost that makes his retail price honest. What I won't do is collude in a unit cost that only works while I am quietly poorer. A supply chain that prints to demand and still pretends it has the economics of a full warehouse is a supply chain practising a confusion. He needs to know the cost. I need to charge it. The reader, if anyone tells him, can decide whether the book is worth what it now is.
A reprint that used to be a pallet
One of his backlist titles surfaced last month, the kind of book that would once have been a walk into the bay with a trolley. We printed it from the file his editor had corrected in the spring. The paper was in our rack because we had agreed to hold that grade, and the hold is on the invoice as a hold, not as a surprise. The binder set the line, ran the copies, spoiled two, ran them again, and the remake sat inside the price we had already explained. It left the same day, which mattered because a shop had asked. It did not leave at the unit cost of the long run we printed when the title was new. He knew that before he sent the email. That knowledge is the whole system working.
The empty bay is still empty, and he should keep it empty. Print on demand is a better shape for a lot of his list than a warehouse full of hope. The shape has a bill. The bill is a higher unit cost, a named place for paper and files, and a rush that is planned as a rush rather than extracted as a favour. He pays the bill out of the money the bay no longer eats. I pay it only when I have been too shy to write it down. We are less shy now. The next title that wakes up in the night can wake up inside a price we have both already seen, and the pallet it replaces can stay a story about the old building, which is where that kind of stock belongs.