The energy argument around short-run digital

# The energy argument around short-run digital Sales had a slide with a pile of makeready sheets on one side and a tidy digital delivery on the other. The engineer had the meter cupboard in his head, and he was not in the mood. Between them sat a short order, posters, a few hundred, wanted

The energy argument around short-run digital

Sales had a slide with a pile of makeready sheets on one side and a tidy digital delivery on the other. The engineer had the meter cupboard in his head, and he was not in the mood. Between them sat a short order, posters, a few hundred, wanted by Friday, and a buyer who had asked which way was the cleaner way. I chaired the meeting because somebody had to stop it becoming a row about virtue. Digital can spare you a lot of paper. The dryer does not care about your spare paper. Both of those sentences fit on the same job, and the buyer deserves the pair.

What you genuinely don't pull

I started with the waste, because the waste is real and I am tired of plants talking it away. On the sheetfed press that poster would have needed plates, a wash if the colour before it was hostile, and a start-up pile while the minder found the lay, the colour, and the fit. For a few hundred finished sheets that pile is not a footnote. I have stood at deliveries where the spoiled sheets looked as serious as the good ones. Chemistry would have been in the fount. Solvent would have been in the wash. None of that is imaginary, and none of it appears as a neat number I am willing to invent. It appears as stillages and drums.

The digital press we would actually use doesn't make a plate for that file. It doesn't hunt colour for twenty minutes with a feeder full of the customer's stock. If the file is decent and the stock is one we already run, the first sheets can be the job, or close to it. That is the honest half of the sales slide. I told sales they could keep it. I also told them to take the photograph of a real makeready off the slide if the photograph was from a carton we would never have printed digitally. A comparison that changes the product in order to win the comparison is how buyers learn to ignore you.

There is a second saving people forget, and it sits in the plate room and the ink rack. A one-off poster doesn't leave us with a spot tin to keep warm for a year, or a set of plates to cage. The file can be reprinted next month from the same stored job, if we have stored it properly. That is material you never ordered. It counts. It is not the whole count.

The machine was already a machine

The engineer waited until I had finished being fair, and then he talked about Tuesday. Tuesday the digital press had been cold. The first job of the day was a short run of those same posters for a different account, and the crew had spent the start of the shift getting the engine to the state where it would lay a sheet they could sign. Dryers, fusers, heaters, whatever that particular box uses to fix the image: they draw power while they are coming up, and they draw it before a saleable sheet exists. Put one lonely order on a cold engine and the order carries the morning. Put the same order behind a queue that has already warmed the line, and the order carries a slice of a day that was happening anyway.

He wasn't making digital guilty. He was refusing the idea that "short" and "already running" are the same condition. Sales had compared a warm story with a cold litho story, which is the mirror of the trick I had just banned. A sheetfed press that is already in colour, with the same ink and the same stock, can take a small extra quantity without a new mountain of makeready. A sheetfed press that is cold, washed, and plated for a different colour cannot. The cleaner route depends on what the building is already doing at the hour the file arrives. A buyer never sees that hour. We do, and if we answer him from a brochure we are guessing about our own diary.

I asked the planner to pull the actual Tuesday. The posters had gone digital because the litho crew was inside a long carton with a special red, and breaking that carton for a few hundred posters would have been vandalism. The digital engine was warmed for a queue of short commercial work. In that hour, digital was the sensible machine, and the sensible machine was also an electrical machine doing what it was bought to do. Sensible is not a synonym for weightless.

Clicks, dryers, and the sheet that still fails

A digital sheet is not free once it has left the stack. The engine charges the sheet with a click, or with ink, and with the heat or the cure that makes the image stay. Coverage matters. A pale poster with a line of type is a different draw from a full-bleed photograph that asks the dryer to deal with a heavy lay. I won't pretend I have a factor that turns those two into a single moral. I will say that we have watched heavy coverage slow a digital job and fill a waste bin with sheets the dryer marked, scuffed, or refused. Those sheets are fewer than a litho makeready on a bad day. They are not zero, and they are made of the customer's stock, which is the expensive kind of zero to miss.

Finishing doesn't convert to a cleaner process by being downstream of a digital press. The guillotine still trims. A wrong cut still ruins a pile. A laminator still warms up, and a lamination on a short run can be the thirstiest part of the afternoon if the laminator was cold and the posters were few. Sales had cropped the slide before finishing. The engineer put finishing back in with one sentence, and the sentence survived into the note we sent the buyer. If your cleaner comparison stops at the print unit, you have stopped before the job stopped.

There is also the habit of leaving the engine up. Warm-up is painful, so crews leave a digital line powered between jobs, through lunch, sometimes through a gap that was meant to be an hour and became three. That power sits on the day's work whether the day's work was virtuous. A litho press left idling is the same kind of habit, and I have chased both. The argument is not that one technology sleeps more purely. The argument is that a plant's real energy behaviour is a set of habits around whatever iron it owns. Buyers who ask only about the process name are asking the easier question.

A short order can still be the dirtier one

We looked at a second job, because one poster was going to become a policy if we let it. A simple price list, very short, uncoated, black and one spot, wanted in three days, and already on a litho press that was running that spot for a longer cousin of the same list. Digital would have meant a different stock, a different look, and a cold start on a machine that had nothing else in that substrate that day. Litho meant a plate and a short extra makeready grafted onto a job that was already right. The makeready was real. It was also smaller than the fuss of building a separate digital route for a list the buyer would compare against last month's list, which had been litho.

Sales didn't love that example. It spoils the slide. It is also the example I trust, because it stops the plant telling every short order that it is a moral victory. Sometimes the short order belongs on digital and the avoided plates and avoided start-up pile are the main material fact. Sometimes the short order is a tail on a litho job, and starting a digital engine, a dryer, and a different stock for it spends a morning to save a stillage you were only partly going to fill. I can't rank those with a carbon factor. I don't have a factor I would sign. I can rank them by asking what the building would have run anyway, what stock the buyer will accept, and how many sheets we expect to throw before someone signs.

European packaging rules and the questionnaires beside them have made buyers ask this question in the language of impact. The language arrives before the plant has a measured answer. That is awkward, and the awkwardness is not a reason to pick a winner in the meeting and type it. A buyer who is told "digital, because waste" will repeat it. A buyer who is told what we avoided and what we still ran can decide, and he can defend the decision when his own colleague asks about electricity. I would rather he heard the electricity from us.

What we wrote, and what we refused to score

The note to the buyer was short enough to read on a phone, which is the length of note that doesn't grow a fake model.

For this poster, on this day, we ran digital. We avoided plates, a litho wash, and a start-up pile on the sheetfed press. The digital engine was already warm inside a queue of short work. The dryer ran. A handful of sheets failed at the engine and at the trim, and they went into the waste stream for that stock. We didn't switch the job to digital because a short run is automatically the cleaner run. We switched it because the litho crew was committed to a carton, the stock was qualified, and the file didn't need a special colour we only hold as ink in a duct.

If the same poster arrives on a morning when the digital line is cold and litho is already up in the right ink, we will say so before we assume the slide still applies. The cleaner job is the one that uses the machine the day has already paid to have ready, and that doesn't spend a pile of the customer's stock learning a colour. Some days that machine is digital. Some days it isn't.

The engineer wanted a line about electricity being the part we can't shrug off. I put it in. Sales wanted a line about the makeready we didn't make. I put that in too. Neither line was allowed to delete the other. That is the whole policy, and it fits on the wall by the planner without a picture of a sad paper pile.

The meeting after the meeting

I kept sales back for ten minutes. The slide can stay in the drawer for a first conversation, if the photograph is from our own waste and the caption says "sometimes." It can't go to a buyer as the answer. The answer is a job, a diary, and a machine state. We agreed that estimating would ask three things before anyone writes "cleaner" on a short-run quote. Was a suitable press already up? Does the stock change if we move process? Where will the rejected sheets and the finishing actually happen? Those are the questions I will ask if I see the word cleaner on a docket.

The engineer, on his way out, said he was less cross. He had expected to be told that electricity was a detail. It is the other half of the same detail. A plant that only counts sheets will buy digital and then be shocked by the dryer. A plant that only counts kilowatts, without a number it has actually read off its own meters, will keep a litho press in makeready out of superstition. I am not going to publish a league table of processes. I am going to keep making the planner say which half of the argument he is in, on that morning, before anyone promises a buyer that the short order was the light one.

Written by

Helen Ward

Sheetfed printer

Runs sheetfed offset and writes up the job that went wrong on her press.

Related articles

Process

Flexo still fits packaging

# Flexo still fits packaging The buyer had been to a presentation, and he arrived wanting the range moved. Film, board, a family of labels, all of it, onto a di...

Process

Print on demand moves the stock and the cost

# Print on demand moves the stock and the cost The publisher showed me an empty bay and he was proud of it. A year ago the bay had held a title that sold steadi...

Process

Versioned packaging is a production problem

# Versioned packaging is a production problem Marketing called it a celebration. A commemorative sleeve, one brand, a dozen pictures, a few lines of type that c...

Process

Print that can be scanned, used and recovered

# Print that can be scanned, used and recovered The code scanned on the flat sheet. I watched the buyer's phone pick it up from the press table, quick and pleas...