Why book print-on-demand is still a small share

# Why book print-on-demand is still a small share The idea is old. Print the copy when someone wants it, instead of printing a pile and hoping the pile matches the demand. Book plants have been able to image a single copy, or a short batch, for a long time. Presses got better at the

Why book print-on-demand is still a small share

The idea is old. Print the copy when someone wants it, instead of printing a pile and hoping the pile matches the demand. Book plants have been able to image a single copy, or a short batch, for a long time. Presses got better at the page. The workflows around single copies got more practised. And the share of pages is still modest. Most pages are still born in a run a publisher placed, printed, and put into a warehouse. That isn't a failure of the brochure. The bottlenecks are the workflow that turns a title into a printable book, the unit cost of one copy against the cost of a run, and the way publishers still order. A new feature on the press doesn't move any of those.

Modest is a description, not a measurement you should invent a figure for. It means the page count of the trade is still dominated by runs. Print-on-demand can be busy, can be a real plant, can be the only sane way to keep a slow title available, and still be a small share of pages. Job count flatters it. A day of single copies feels like a lot of work. A first printing of a book that sells through is a lot of pages. Confusing the two is how people announce that the model has taken over, while the pallets leaving a conventional book plant say otherwise.

The file in the archive isn't an order

A title becomes a printable book when a set of decisions agree. The interior file, the cover, the paper, the bulk that paper will make at that page count, the spine built from that bulk, the bind, the ISBN, the barcode, the trim. Miss the bulk and the spine's type slides off the spine. Miss the trim and the margins the designer trusted get cut. Miss the cover finish and you have a book that doesn't match the edition the shop is selling. On a long run, a printer and a publisher's production editor have traditionally caught a certain amount of this during makeready, because a long start has people looking. On a single copy there is no crowd of copies in which someone notices. The file either arrives decided, or a person at the plant decides it, one title at a time.

Most files in a publisher's archive weren't built for that. They were built for a run. The cover was drawn for a known bulk on a known paper, in a year when someone was paying attention to that title and no other. Fonts, bleed, and the spine were fixed by hand, then forgotten. Rights splits and territorial editions multiply the covers and sometimes the interiors. A backlist of thousands of titles is not a backlist of thousands of ready books. It's a backlist of files that each need a check before the first copy is allowed to go out as if it were routine. Until that check is done, and stored, every "order" is really a small production job. That's a workflow ceiling. It sits upstream of whatever images the page.

The order path has a second ceiling, between the shop and the plant. Someone buys a book. The seller's system knows a title, an edition, and an address. The plant needs those, plus the specification, without a person retyping them into a ticket and hoping the edition matches the file. Where that link is solid, a copy can move. Where it isn't, the plant is taking emails, and emails don't become a large page count. They become a queue of exceptions. Returns make it worse. A warehouse that thinks in cartons, and a retailer that can send a carton back, don't automatically know what to do with a book that was printed for one reader and then refused. The unglamorous plumbing, identity of the edition, and what happens when it comes back, is a reason the page share stays modest while the idea stays obviously sensible.

One copy carries the handling

The cost difference isn't a mystery, and it doesn't need a price list to explain. A run pays a makeready once. Every copy after that shares the plates, the start, and the make-ready of the binding line, and the copies leave as cartons on a pallet to a distributor who already knows how to take a pallet. A single copy pays the handling every time. Someone issues the paper. The interior is imaged. The cover is imaged. The book is bound. It is packed as one book. It is shipped as one book, often to one address. The imaging being plate-free removes one cost, the plates and the offset start. It doesn't remove the bind, the pack, and the journey of a single object.

That's why print-on-demand wins where a run would be waste, and loses the argument where a run would be sold. A slow title that might sell a few copies, or might not, is a bad candidate for a printing that then sits, or gets pulped, or gets remaindered. Printing it when it's ordered throws away the waste rather than the chance to sell. A frontlist title the publisher expects to sell through is the opposite case. The run's makeready is going to be absorbed by copies they already believe they can move, and those copies travel in bulk. The on-demand copy is still a complete handling event. You can prefer it for other reasons, risk, speed of a reprint decision, a title you don't want to hold. You shouldn't pretend the handling got cheap because the press has no plates. The handling is most of the object.

Paper and bind don't scale down neatly either. A run buys a making of paper and a binding setup that stays in place. A single copy wants that paper now, in a rack, in the right shade and bulk, and a binding line that can change from one trim and one thickness to the next without a long reset. Plants that do this well have narrowed the options on purpose: certain trims, certain papers, certain binds. That narrowing is what makes the unit thinkable. It also means a publisher whose book doesn't fit the narrowed path is back in the world of a specified run, with a specified paper, which is the world where on-demand was never the offer. The modest share has this gate in it. A great many pages are specified in ways a single-copy path has chosen not to hold.

Publishers still order in runs

The purchasing habit is older than the press, and it hasn't been replaced by the availability of the other model. Publishers order a print run. They hold inventory. Inventory sits on the accounts as stock. Retailers take books on terms that assume a carton, a warehouse, and the possibility of sending unsold copies back. Reprint decisions are made when stock falls to a level somebody chose. All of that is a system. Moving a title to print-on-demand isn't a change of printer inside that system. It's a change to who holds the risk, and to when the book physically exists. The sales team, the retailer, and the accountant all have to agree, or the title stays on the run even if a plant would happily image it tonight.

Some categories already agreed, which is why the model is real without being most of the pages. Academic and specialist titles, and the deep backlist, moved where the run was already a poor fit: demand too thin, too uncertain, or too spread out to justify printing and holding. The success of those categories is sometimes used as proof that everything else is late. It isn't late. Frontlist that a retailer wants on a table for a promotion, in quantity, on a date, still wants a run and a pallet. Illustrated books, heavy colour, and papers chosen as part of the design still get ordered as specified runs, because the single-copy path's narrowed materials don't include the object. Children's books with particular covers and bindings, anything where the physical book is the product rather than a container for text, keep the same pattern. The pages in those runs are why the overall share of on-demand pages stays modest while the backlist story sounds complete.

There's a further habit inside the reprint. Even publishers who use on-demand for the tail will often flip a title back to a run when it wakes up. A prize, a season, an unexpected demand, and the arithmetic of handling one copy stops being the arithmetic they want. The plant that printed the single copies doesn't automatically receive the run. The run goes where runs go. So the on-demand pages are, in part, the quiet period of a title's life, and the busy period leaves. Count pages across a year and the quiet period doesn't catch the busy one. That's an ordering pattern. It will not be changed by showing the publisher a sharper text page.

What a brochure can't fix

A brochure about the press answers whether the page can be imaged well. For a large part of text-driven book work, that question was answered years ago. Buyers who still aren't placing the bulk of their pages this way aren't waiting for a finer type or a wider sheet. They're living with files that aren't decided, with a shop-to-plant link that isn't there, with a unit that carries its own bind and its own postage, and with a company that still buys runs because its retailers, its warehouse, and its accounts are built for runs.

If you're a plant, the useful work is on those bottlenecks, and only where they actually move. A checked backlist, a spine that builds itself from the paper you really hold, an order that arrives as data rather than as a message, a short list of trims and papers you can bind without a meeting. That's how on-demand pages grow, title by title, inside the categories where a run is the wrong object. It isn't how you capture the first printing of a book the publisher already intends to sell in bulk. If you're a publisher, the mirror image is the same. Don't ask the press to fix a returns policy, a pallet-shaped retailer, or an archive of covers drawn for a bulk you no longer remember. The press can make the page. The share of pages stays modest until the order, the file, and the handling of one copy are cheaper and clearer than a run, for that title, not in a brochure.

Written by

Ruth Keller

Quality

Reads the sheet, the barcode and the proof, and says what she will not sign.

Related articles

Process

Flexo still fits packaging

# Flexo still fits packaging The buyer had been to a presentation, and he arrived wanting the range moved. Film, board, a family of labels, all of it, onto a di...

Process

Print on demand moves the stock and the cost

# Print on demand moves the stock and the cost The publisher showed me an empty bay and he was proud of it. A year ago the bay had held a title that sold steadi...

Process

Versioned packaging is a production problem

# Versioned packaging is a production problem Marketing called it a celebration. A commemorative sleeve, one brand, a dozen pictures, a few lines of type that c...

Process

Print that can be scanned, used and recovered

# Print that can be scanned, used and recovered The code scanned on the flat sheet. I watched the buyer's phone pick it up from the press table, quick and pleas...