Where any rise in digital print share comes from

# Where any rise in digital print share comes from Don't start with a share. A share is a result, and it's a slippery one, because the answer depends on the denominator you chose: one plant, one buyer's spend, jobs, pages, or packs. Whatever figure someone would like to put on it, the figure isn't

Where any rise in digital print share comes from

Don't start with a share. A share is a result, and it's a slippery one, because the answer depends on the denominator you chose: one plant, one buyer's spend, jobs, pages, or packs. Whatever figure someone would like to put on it, the figure isn't the useful question. The useful question is which work actually leaves offset, and which work stays, when digital capacity is available to the same buyers.

The long base load stays. Where digital work grows inside a plant or a buyer's mix, the growth is made of reprints, of versions, and of the tail of a product line. It isn't made of the weekly long job flipping over because a digital press has been installed down the road. If you can't name the reprints, the versions, and the tail, you don't have an explanation. You have a mood.

The base load has a reason to stay

Offset, sheetfed or web, is built to absorb a makeready across a long run of the same form. Plates, a start, a colour OK, and then copies. The longer the run of that same form, the more the start is diluted into the work. The base load is the set of jobs long enough, and stable enough, for that dilution to be the point of the process. A publication that's still one edition and still long. A carton that fills the pipeline for a listing that isn't going away. A catalogue that's one version. A label that keeps running because the SKU keeps selling as one SKU.

That work doesn't leave out of curiosity. Moving it would mean paying a different cost structure for a job whose advantage was length. The press already scheduled for it, the plates that may still exist for the same form, the crew that knows the stock, the finishing tooled around that sheet: those are reasons to stay. They're stronger than a general wish to move the famous jobs onto the new device. Plan the year as if the base load is about to stand up and walk, and you'll buy capacity for work that's still content where it is.

You can see the distinction on one schedule without any market arithmetic. The offset week has a backbone of repeating long jobs. Around that backbone sit the shorts everyone resents, because each one spends a makeready the long job could have used. The resentment is real. It isn't evidence that the backbone is leaving. It's evidence that the shorts are in the wrong room, which is a different, and more useful, observation.

Ganging those shorts onto a long form doesn't promote them into the base load. You've hidden several faces inside one start, and you've hidden their deadlines inside somebody else's run. The gang holds only while the faces are willing to wait, and to share a stock and a colour OK. When a retailer wants its variant on its own date, the gang breaks and the pieces leave one at a time. What left is the versions and the tail. The long form they were sheltering in is still there, still long, still the job the offset press was bought to run.

Reprints leave after the first run has already happened

A reprint isn't a new job with an old label. The first printing was offset. The file is known. Someone signed the colour. Then the buyer needs more, and the more is plainly not another base-load run. Plates may have been stripped. The press is full of the next long form. Stealing a makeready from that form, to top up a job that was already printed, costs schedule as much as it costs materials. The interruption is the thing the offset plant feels. The buyer mostly feels the delay, and then, if you're careless, the mismatch.

Digital takes the top-up when the colour can be brought close enough that the new pieces don't look like a different printing in the same delivery. Stock is the quiet half of that match. The first run had a shade, a coating, and a making. A top-up on "the usual" stock from a later making can fail beside the retained sheet even when the device is behaving, because the buyer compares sheets, not profiles. The plant that keeps this work names the stock as part of the target and keeps a sheet from the first run to compare against. That's the condition, and there isn't a way around it. If the match fails, the reprint stays on offset, or it doesn't happen, or it happens and comes back. A plant that keeps reprints is a plant that can repeat a signed colour on the same class of stock, job after job. A plant that wins one top-up and misses the match doesn't get asked the next time. The work returns to the plates, and the digital press is left with the story of a trial.

Reprints are also where people misread their own order book. A stretch of top-ups can fill the digital diary with job numbers while the sheets themselves stay short. Job count and the amount of work aren't the same movement. Staff the press against the noise of the diary and you'll feel busy. Look at what those jobs actually are, and you'll see top-ups of work whose first, long printing never left offset. Say that plainly when someone asks why the digital room is frantic and the offset room still holds the volume that pays the crews. Frantic isn't a share. It's a pattern of short returns.

Versions leave because each one is a new start

A version is a language, a retailer panel, a region, a legal line, a price flash, a seasonal face on a product that otherwise stays put. On offset, each one wants plates and a makeready, even when the picture barely changed. On digital, each one wants a file that's been checked against the master. The split follows from that difference. It doesn't follow from a preference for one process having a better brochure. The more a buyer's product becomes a family, the more of the family is version-work, and version-work is what peels away from the long press.

The hero can stay, and in the usual case it should. A national pack on offset and the retailer variants on digital is a coherent arrangement. A national pack described as having "moved" because the variants were a nuisance is a different claim, and it's usually wrong. The variants were the nuisance. They were spending starts. The national pack was the load, and the load didn't become a variant just because the variants found a better home. Quote the split that way and the buyer recognises their own list. Quote it as a conversion of everything and they'll correct you with the purchase order for the hero, which is still sitting on the offset schedule.

Versions also explain why two buyers in the same trade don't behave alike. One still sells one product, in one market, with one face. Nothing structural is pushing their work off the long press. Another sells through many retailers, or many languages, or a run of short promotions that each need their own face. Their version count climbed. The offset plant started to spend the week starting rather than running. Digital doesn't take the trade. It takes the buyer whose product stopped being a single form. If your sales story can't tell those buyers apart, you'll chase the first one with a pitch built for the second, and you'll lose both: one because you didn't understand the load, the other because a rival did.

The tail was never the base load

Every line has a tail. The slow colourway. The odd size that completes a range. The SKU that has to exist in the catalogue so the range doesn't look gappy. The title that still sells, and never in a quantity that absorbs a makeready. This work was often forced onto offset, or batched until someone hoped it had become long enough, which is another way of saying it was printed late. It didn't defect from the base load. It was never in the base load. Digital takes it because the problem was the start, and there was never going to be a run long enough to swallow the start.

This is the movement that gets dressed up as a general shift. It shouldn't be. The tail moving is the tail stopping being a parasite on the long press. The offset schedule gets makereadies back. The digital press gets work that's short by its nature, with all the file-checking and colour-matching that short work demands. Describe the change as the market flipping, and the next step in the fantasy is to go looking for the hero SKUs inside the tail. They aren't there. The tail is slow sellers and odd sizes. That's its definition. A press filled with the tail is a real business only if you cost the tail as the tail, not as a down payment on the base load you haven't won. Costing it properly means the file check, the colour match, and the finishing setup are allowed to be a large part of a short order. Pretend the tail has the economics of the hero, and you'll underprice the very work that was willing to move.

What any rise is actually made of

Put the three movements side by side and a rise, where one exists, becomes describable without a pretended measurement. Reprints of jobs whose first run stayed on offset. Versions that multiplied until the makeready was the thing you were selling. The tail that should never have been queued behind a long form. Add those in one plant, or in one buyer's spend, and digital's part of the mix can grow while the repeating long jobs sit still. Remove them, and there may be nothing to explain. No mystery process is required, and no claim about the wider trade has to be invented to make the local pattern true.

The planning mistake is to hear "rise" and forecast that the base will shrink to feed it. Sometimes a base load does get shorter, because the buyer's demand shrank, or a publication lost its single long edition, or a pack became a family of faces. That's a change in the order. It isn't a property of the printing process, and it isn't a schedule you can assume for the buyer next door whose product is still one long form. Capacity bought to catch a base load that was always going to stay will stand there, competent and underfed. The reprints, the versions, and the tail will go to the plant that organised for those, and that didn't wait for the hero job to defect out of loyalty to a trend.

Written by

Owen Blake

Packaging printer

Works on web, gravure and flexo packaging, from the reel to the finished pack.

Related articles

Process

Flexo still fits packaging

# Flexo still fits packaging The buyer had been to a presentation, and he arrived wanting the range moved. Film, board, a family of labels, all of it, onto a di...

Process

Print on demand moves the stock and the cost

# Print on demand moves the stock and the cost The publisher showed me an empty bay and he was proud of it. A year ago the bay had held a title that sold steadi...

Process

Versioned packaging is a production problem

# Versioned packaging is a production problem Marketing called it a celebration. A commemorative sleeve, one brand, a dozen pictures, a few lines of type that c...

Process

Print that can be scanned, used and recovered

# Print that can be scanned, used and recovered The code scanned on the flat sheet. I watched the buyer's phone pick it up from the press table, quick and pleas...