Inkjet grows while web offset orders shrink

# Inkjet grows while web offset orders shrink The heatset was warm and idle, which is the expensive way to be idle. The oven was off. The reel stands had a web on them from yesterday's attempt at a run that had been pulled forward and then pulled back. Across the aisle, in a bay

Inkjet grows while web offset orders shrink

The heatset was warm and idle, which is the expensive way to be idle. The oven was off. The reel stands had a web on them from yesterday's attempt at a run that had been pulled forward and then pulled back. Across the aisle, in a bay we built later, the inkjet web was moving. Not fast in the way a heatset man means fast. Moving, with a catalogue that changed its cover every few thousand copies and a body that stayed put. I manage this works. People ask me, with a look, whether the inkjet has replaced the web. It hasn't. I can show you the jobs on the board this morning, and the length of each one is the whole answer.

We still have both machines because both kinds of order still exist. What has changed is the mix. The long publication run, the one the heatset was bought for, arrives less often and shorter when it arrives. The awkward middle, which used to be forced onto the web or forced onto a sheetfed and hated both, has become the inkjet's ordinary day. If I talk as if one machine ate the other, I will buy the wrong thing next and I will teach the schedulers to lie. So I talk about lengths.

A morning on the board

Three jobs were live enough to argue about before nine. The first was a weekly magazine we have printed for years. One version. A familiar paper. A run that fills a shift and gives the folder a long, steady diet of the same signature. The second was a catalogue for a retailer who used to be a heatset customer and who now sends a body in one language and covers that differ by region, plus an insert that is not in every copy. The third was a book block, a single title, a quiet quantity, the sort of order a publisher sends when they are topping up a backlist title and do not want a warehouse.

The scheduler had the weekly on the heatset already, and he was right. He had the catalogue half written onto the heatset as well, out of memory, and the book block sitting in a margin because nobody likes a short book on a big web. I made him wipe the catalogue off the heatset. I put it on the inkjet. I sent the book block to a sheetfed binder's line we use when the quantity would make a web spend its morning getting ready and its afternoon regretting it. Three jobs. Three homes. The argument is not about which process is modern. It is about which process gets out of its own start and into saleable copies before the order is used up.

Where the web still earns the oven

The weekly is the clean case, so I'll stay with it until it is boring, because boring is where web offset still makes sense. The file is stable. The printer's imposition is known. The paper is a reel we can splice without a conference. Colour has to match last week's issue closely enough that a reader who buys both does not think the magazine changed its clothes. The run is long enough that the start-up, the waste off the splicer, the time to settle the folder, and the plates are a toll at the beginning of a journey that pays.

On that kind of order the heatset is the right machine in a way the inkjet is not obliged to imitate. The oven is there because the ink needs it. The speed of the line, once it is settled, is the point of the line. The crew are people who listen to a folder the way other people listen to an engine. You do not break that up into versions without paying a second time for every break. A regional cover on a heatset weekly is possible. It is also a way to turn one good run into several nervous ones. We do it when the publisher insists and the quantities still deserve a web. We don't pretend it is free.

There are other orders in the same family. A retail circular that is genuinely one version across a whole territory, long enough to swallow makeready, is still a web job if the paper and the folder agree. A book block of one title, when the publisher has committed to a long printing and the paper is a web paper, belongs here too. I am not romantic about it. If the order is long and stable, the cylinder and the oven are a cheap way to lay a lot of ink on a lot of paper, and cheap, on a long run, is the whole commercial idea. Inkjet ink and inkjet heads have their own bills, and those bills do not become small just because the machine is newer. On a long, unchanging run I would be a fool to move the weekly off the heatset to make a point.

The shrinkage is real in the schedule even if I refuse to dress it up as a figure. The weekly's run is shorter than the run we installed the press for. Some titles that used to be a heatset habit have gone to fewer issues, or to a length where I stand at the reel and know we will spend too much of the day in start-up. Directories that were a month of webs became a file people search instead of a book people lift. I don't need a chart. I need the empty hours on a press that still has a crew. Those hours are the orders shrinking. They are not the inkjet's victory lap. The inkjet cannot print the weekly better. It prints different orders.

The middle the inkjet actually wants

The catalogue is the middle, and the middle is where I will defend the inkjet without letting it become a religion. Each regional cover is long enough to be a nuisance on a sheetfed press and short enough to be a crime on the heatset. If I put the whole catalogue on the heatset, I will plate every cover, I will stop, I will restart, and the start-up waste will be a cousin of the quantity. The body, which is long and shared, would have liked the web. The covers spoil that liking. If I put the whole thing on a sheetfed offset, I will be making ready all week and handling sheets that only wanted to be a web in the first place. The inkjet takes the body and the covers in one grammar. The file changes at a planned copy. The paper keeps moving. There is no plate for the cover that marketing will change again on Thursday.

That is the awkward length. Too long for sheetfed makeready to stay polite. Too broken, or too short of a true web run, for the oven to be the hero. Catalogues with versions. Books that are a series of moderate titles rather than one giant printing. Manuals that share a body and swap a chapter. Direct mail that is long in total and personal in the line of type that matters. I have watched our inkjet spend a day on that kind of work and come out with a pallet that is honest. Saleable copies from early in the run. A change of file without a wash-up. A cost that belongs to the copies, not to a start-up ritual designed for a different decade.

It has conditions, and the crew are stricter about them than the brochure was. The paper has to be one the heads have already met. A bargain reel that is a surprise will show you a surprise. The file has to be the file, because there is no plate-maker to catch a font that went missing. Colour is a managed colour, approved on this process, not a memory of a heatset flesh tone from five years ago. When a buyer arrives with a heatset proof and a demand that the inkjet match it on a different paper, we stop and make a proof on the inkjet. The middle is not a place where you inherit the old standard for free. It is a place where you set a standard the machine can keep.

Some jobs in the middle still go back to the web, and I want that said plainly. If the versions collapse, if the retailer sends one cover after all, if the run swells back to a length that makes start-up a small toll, the heatset takes it. We have done that twice this season. The scheduler hates the uncertainty. I would rather he hated it than hide it. A process earns the job it fits today, not the job it fitted when we poured the pit.

What should never see either machine

The book block in the margin is the other lesson. A short top-up of one title does not belong on the heatset, and it does not belong on a high-volume inkjet web either if a sheet-fed digital line, or a short-run book line, can do it without a reel. I am not going to dress a handful of copies as a web order so that a machine looks busy. Busy at the wrong length is waste with a running counter. The publisher's printer, in that case, might be us on a smaller line, or it might be a book plant that lives on exactly this. Letting it go is cleaner than stretching it.

There is a mirror mistake on the inkjet. A salesperson will try to put the weekly on it because the weekly is famous and the inkjet is the machine he wants to talk about. The weekly would run. It would also cost us the advantage of the oven and the folder we already trust, and it would fill the inkjet with work that cannot use the inkjet's real trick, which is change. Filling a flexible machine with inflexible work is how you go blind. You look busy. You have used the new press as a worse copy of the old one.

I walked the heatset crew in the afternoon. They had the weekly up, and the folder sounded like itself. One of them asked if the catalogue had been taken away because the web had failed. It hadn't failed. The order had the wrong shape. I told him the next long, single version was his, and that I would not invent one to soothe the afternoon. He understood. Crews understand length faster than managers do, because they feel the start-up in their hands. Managers feel it later, in a margin that never quite explains itself.

Shrinkage is not a handover

Orders on the web have shrunk, and some of them have shrunk into the length the inkjet was built to take. That is a move. It is not a replacement. The heatset in this building still has a weekly, and it still has a claim on any run that is long, stable, and kind to an oven. The inkjet has a claim on the broken middle, the versioned catalogue, the run that would spend its life in makeready anywhere else. Sheetfed and short-run lines have a claim on the small order that should never have been dressed up as a web.

If I add capacity, I add it where the middle is growing, and I keep the heatset for the work that still fills it. If the weekly left, I would not automatically give its pit to the inkjet. I would ask whether the orders replacing it have the inkjet's shape, or whether they have left print, or left for a plant closer to a binder who already has the right length. A press is a claim about the orders you believe will keep arriving. The idle hour this morning was a claim we used to make, meeting an order book that has become shorter and more broken. The inkjet running next door was a different claim, and it was the one the catalogue could live inside.

I left the board with the three jobs in three homes. Tomorrow's board will try to blur them, because habit is strong and empty press time is loud. My job is to keep the lengths visible. Web offset still makes sense when the run is long enough to pay the oven for existing. Inkjet makes sense when the run is an awkward middle that changes. Neither sentence cancels the other. The plant that pretends one of them has won is the plant that will put the next job on the wrong reel.

Written by

Priya Shah

Prepress

Makes plates and proofs, and sends the file back when the press cannot fix it.

Related articles

Process

Flexo still fits packaging

# Flexo still fits packaging The buyer had been to a presentation, and he arrived wanting the range moved. Film, board, a family of labels, all of it, onto a di...

Process

Print on demand moves the stock and the cost

# Print on demand moves the stock and the cost The publisher showed me an empty bay and he was proud of it. A year ago the bay had held a title that sold steadi...

Process

Versioned packaging is a production problem

# Versioned packaging is a production problem Marketing called it a celebration. A commemorative sleeve, one brand, a dozen pictures, a few lines of type that c...

Process

Print that can be scanned, used and recovered

# Print that can be scanned, used and recovered The code scanned on the flat sheet. I watched the buyer's phone pick it up from the press table, quick and pleas...