Four ways to print flexible packaging

# Four ways to print flexible packaging The pouch on the desk could have been printed four ways, and each way would have been right for a different pouch. Gravure, with a cylinder for every colour and a run long enough to make the cylinders boring. Flexo, with plates, for the broad middle of the

Four ways to print flexible packaging

The pouch on the desk could have been printed four ways, and each way would have been right for a different pouch. Gravure, with a cylinder for every colour and a run long enough to make the cylinders boring. Flexo, with plates, for the broad middle of the work where the design lives a while and then changes. Digital, with no plates at all, for the versions and the late legal line. Offset with an energy-curable ink, for a film or a foil that won't take a conventional oil-based ink, in a plant that already knows offset and a run length where a plate still makes sense. The process isn't a badge. It's a fit between the job and the tool. Pick first by what the job is, and keep a clear eye on the job each process is bad at. A press that can print film is not a press that should print every film that comes through the door.

What follows is that fit, not a league table. A workflow can carry the job bag to whichever press you name. It can't tell you the film wanted a cylinder, or that the white will look starved, or that the converter at the end of the line has never seen this ink before. That judgement stays with the plant. The software gets the route after you've made it.

Gravure, when the design is going to stay

Gravure engraves the image into a cylinder, lays ink into those cells, and prints it onto film with a consistency that long-run buyers come looking for. Snacks, confectionery, pet food, the pouch that will be the same pouch for a long time: this is the work gravure is for. Reverse print, then laminate, is a normal shape for it. The colour, once the cylinders are right, holds across a run that would exhaust a conversation about plates. You pay for that up front, in the engraving and in the wait, and you pay again if the artwork moves, because a changed headline is a changed cylinder, not a changed file.

The bad fit is the job that will not sit still. A promotional version, a test market, a design the brand is still arguing about, a line of flavours that each exist for a short season. The cylinder cost and the lead time eat those jobs before the press has a chance to show how well it prints. So does any copy that has to change after the cylinders are cut. If the buyer's lawyer is still in the file, you are not ready to engrave, however hungry the press is. Gravure is also a poor home for a very short filling of an existing design when you don't already have the cylinders. Reprinting from stored cylinders is one thing. Cutting new ones to top up a small shortage is how a simple problem becomes an expensive one. Send that shortage somewhere that doesn't need a new tool, or hold it until the next real run.

A plant that runs gravure already knows the other discipline. Solvent or water, the drying, the smell, the laminate that has to stick to this ink and this film. None of that is a reason to refuse a long, stable design. It is a reason to refuse a long, stable design whose structure you haven't qualified. The press being excellent doesn't qualify the bag.

Flexo, the broad middle, and the jobs it shouldn't be offered

Flexo prints from a relief plate, photopolymer in the usual modern case, mounted on a sleeve or a cylinder, with an anilox roller metering the ink. It is the workhorse of flexible packaging for a reason. Runs that are serious without being gravure-eternal. Several designs in a week. A remake when the art changes, cheaper and faster than a new cylinder, though not free and not instant. Spots, process, coatings, the wide web and the narrower one. A competent flexo plant can hold a brand colour and feed a converter, and most of the pouches in a supermarket have met a plate like this at some point in their family history.

The bad fit begins where people pretend the plate is free. A handful of pouches for a meeting, a one-off sample that has to look like production, a version so short that making and mounting the plates costs more trouble than the buyer will ever see: digital, or a proper proofing route, will serve them better. Flexo also meets its edge on pictures the plant has already failed. A vignette that has to stay open in the highlights, on a film where this press and this plate-and-anilox combination has broken it up before, is a known bad fit. You don't need a new theory of it. You have the old sheet. Heavy coverage that this ink system pinholes on this film is the same kind of evidence. Don't take the job to prove the last failure was a fluke, unless something real has changed: the plate, the ink, the anilox you actually use, the film. Hope isn't a change.

The other bad fit is the opposite end. One design, enormous and stable, of the kind gravure exists for, where the buyer came to you because they want that long-run consistency and a unit cost a plate process will struggle to defend. Taking it on flexo because the press happens to be free can be a decent commercial decision for a while. It stops being decent when you're remaking plates to chase a consistency the cylinder would have held, and calling the chase a service. Match the length and the stillness of the design to the tool. Flexo wins the middle. It doesn't have to win the extremes to be the centre of the plant.

Digital, when the file is the job

Digital flexible work earns its place when the printing has to change faster than a plate room can follow. Many artworks, late copy, regional lines, a serial or a code that alters within the reel, a test pack the brand wants on the real film before they commit a cylinder or a plate. No plates, no cylinders, a queue instead of a tool store. For those jobs the unit cost can be higher and still be the cheap answer, because the alternative's cost is time and tools. White ink, where the film is clear or metallised and the design needs something to sit on, is part of the same offer. If the press can lay that white well enough for the product, you have a production route. If the white is a stain and the brand needs a solid ground, you have a proof.

The bad fit is the long single design that doesn't change, the one where plates or cylinders pay for themselves and the converting line wants a pace and a discipline this digital press doesn't have. You're allowed to print some of that work when you're filling the machine. You should not build the promise of the company on it. The buyer will compare unit cost once the novelty has cooled, and they will be right to. Other bad fits are physical. A metallic the press can't lay. A film the transport can't hold in register. An opaque white the design depends on and the print can't reach. A structure that must be laminated, where this ink and this adhesive haven't been qualified together, or a food use where you haven't got a position your customer's auditor will accept. Don't borrow that qualification from a different film, a different ink set, or a different press in the group. Qualification is a particular fact. "Digital can do flexible" is a slogan.

Treat the file with the same suspicion you'd give a cylinder. Version names, a person releasing the reel, a colour target on the real film rather than on a sheet that felt similar. The front end will print what you send. It won't know the lawyer hated the claim. Late copy is the reason the job came here. Unchecked late copy is the reason it will be reprinted.

Offset with energy-curable ink, a fit with a narrow door

Offset with an energy-curable ink, UV, LED-UV or electron beam, exists for surfaces that won't absorb a conventional oil-based offset ink, and for plants that already know how to run offset. The ink cures because energy acts on it, not because the substrate drinks it. That opens films, foils, some lidstock and sleeves, and other flexible or semi-flexible pieces that sit naturally near a sheetfed or web offset hall. Plates are relatively cheap. The skills, the colour habits, the makeready, are ones an offset crew already has. For a medium run of a design that suits a plate, on a substrate you've proved the ink will cure and key on, this is a serious route rather than a curiosity.

The door is narrow, and the bad fits are obvious once you stand in it. A huge web of thin snack film, with a repeat and an inline converting line built around gravure, is not a sheetfed offset job and may not be your web offset job either. If you haven't got the converting, the lamination, or the pace that line expects, printing the film only moves the problem to the end of the aisle. A very short, highly versioned run is the other miss: you'll spend the advantage of offset on plates and makereadies, while a digital press would have taken the versions without the tools. And a food pack where the buyer wants a signed food-contact position for this ink on this film, which you don't have, is not a job you "see how it goes" on. Energy-curable inks differ. A signature for one combination isn't a signature for the next. Get the position, or leave the job on a process that already has it.

Curing has to be real on the reel or the pile you'll ship. A sheet that feels dry and then blocks, or a wind that smells of work unfinished, is a failure of fit even if the picture looked right. The crew needs to know the signs on your kit, and the kit needs to be the kit you qualified, not a lamp or a beam setting borrowed from a carton job that ran last week on board. Write down the combination that worked: ink, film, lamp or beam setup by the name you use in the plant, the laminate if there is one. Don't invent a number to make the note look scientific. The note is there so the next shift repeats a success, not so it satisfies a column.

Let the bad fit decide

A useful way to choose is to ask which process would make this particular job look stupid. Gravure looks stupid on a design that's still moving. Flexo looks stupid on a handful of pouches, or on a vignette you've already watched it break, or on a vast unchanging run you're only taking to keep the press warm. Digital looks stupid on a long single SKU you can't defend on cost, on a white or a metallic you can't lay, and on a food structure you haven't qualified. Energy-curable offset looks stupid on a converting line you don't have, on a swarm of versions, and on an ink-and-film pair nobody has signed.

The pouch on the desk gets one of the four when the answers come out clean, and it gets a refusal when they don't. Refusal is a production skill. The job bag can record the route you chose and the reason you refused the others. What it can't record, unless a person writes it after looking, is the pinholing you remember, the white you couldn't reach, the cylinder you shouldn't cut yet. Hand the software the route. Keep the bad fit in the conversation, where a press owner can still act on it.

Written by

Daniel Okonkwo

Works office

Turns an enquiry into a job bag, and a finished pile into a delivery.

Related articles

Process

Flexo still fits packaging

# Flexo still fits packaging The buyer had been to a presentation, and he arrived wanting the range moved. Film, board, a family of labels, all of it, onto a di...

Process

Print on demand moves the stock and the cost

# Print on demand moves the stock and the cost The publisher showed me an empty bay and he was proud of it. A year ago the bay had held a title that sold steadi...

Process

Versioned packaging is a production problem

# Versioned packaging is a production problem Marketing called it a celebration. A commemorative sleeve, one brand, a dozen pictures, a few lines of type that c...

Process

Print that can be scanned, used and recovered

# Print that can be scanned, used and recovered The code scanned on the flat sheet. I watched the buyer's phone pick it up from the press table, quick and pleas...