Book printing is moving toward print on demand
# Book printing is moving toward print on demand The file arrived on a Tuesday with no quantity a binder could respect. A publisher we have printed for years sent a novel we used to make as a pallet, then another pallet, then an argument about the copies still in our warehouse in March. This
Book printing is moving toward print on demand
The file arrived on a Tuesday with no quantity a binder could respect. A publisher we have printed for years sent a novel we used to make as a pallet, then another pallet, then an argument about the copies still in our warehouse in March. This time the note said the file should be held, and the copies should come as the orders came. A bookshop had asked for a few. An online seller might ask next week. I read it in the doorway of the bay where their last title was still sitting, unsold, because the contract had been written for a warehouse and the warehouse had turned out to be ours.
They don't want that bay. I don't want it either. Print on demand is the name they use for the refusal. What it means on this floor is smaller and ruder. We receive a file. We receive a trickle. Then we have a fight about what one copy costs, because they are comparing it with a memory of a long run, and the memory has had the warehouse edited out.
What the long printing was really selling
The old order was a bet. The publisher guessed how many people would want the book, and we printed the guess. If the guess was high, somebody stored the difference. If it was low, we went back to press and the unit cost of the reprint looked worse than the first printing, which is a conversation I have had with my shoes on their carpet. The unit cost they remember, the one that makes a single print-on-demand copy look greedy, was a print cost spread over a number they hoped was true. It was never the cost of the book as a thing that might not sell.
I can walk you to the cost they forget. That bay. The rent on it. The copies that came back from a bookshop in a scuffed carton and could not go out again as new. The title we pulped because a new edition had made the old one a liar, and the paper was ours to dispose of because the job had been printed and paid and then abandoned. None of that appeared in the unit cost on the estimate they still quote at me. The estimate was honest about ink and paper and binding for the quantity ordered. It was silent about the quantity that never met a reader.
So when they say they are moving to print on demand, they are moving the bet. They would rather pay more for a copy that has a reader attached than pay less for a copy that might live here until we both pretend it was a success. I agree with the move. I don't agree with the comparison they bring to it. If you take the old unit cost, strip out the dead stock, and hold it next to a single copy made on a Thursday, the single copy loses. It should lose that contest. The contest is the wrong one.
A file, then a trickle
What actually arrives now is not a job bag in the old sense. It is a file, and then a series of small instructions that the file should become books.
The file is the first fight, and it is a quieter fight than the price. A traditional book printer receives, or used to receive, pages that a production person has already made into something a press can trust. Imposition understood. Fonts embedded. A cover built to the board we use, with a spine that matches the bulk of the paper we agreed. The files that come for this new arrangement are often one step earlier. A designer has exported something that looked right on a screen. A heading has fallen off a page. A picture is heavy in a way that will look dark on the paper we actually run. The cover is the cover of the offset edition, built for a bulk this copy will not have, because a short-run paper and a long-run paper are not the same thickness, and the spine is a measurement, not a decoration.
Somebody in this building has to look. If we don't look, we will bind a book that the publisher then compares with the shop copy from the long printing, and we will lose an argument we could have had on the Tuesday the file arrived. Looking is labour. It does not shrink because the order is one copy or twenty. A file check is a file check. On a long run it hid. On a trickle it is a large part of the day's work, and a publisher who thinks the printing "just happens" from a PDF has not stood next to the person who opened it.
Then the orders. A few copies for a shop that still likes to have the title. A few more for an online seller. A spike, once, when something outside the trade noticed the book, and we ran longer than the trickle for a week and then went back to quiet. A month with nothing, during which the file still has to be the file, ready, because the promise they bought is that the book exists without existing in a bay. That promise is a kind of stock. It is not paper stock. It is attention, a stored setting, a cover that has been proved, a binding method that we know will look like the edition they still sell in the shops that took the long run.
The trickle is awkward in a plant that grew up on pallets. A binder set for a long run is a miserable place to make twenty books. The makeready of the line, the warm-up, the first copies that are not quite the copies, all of that used to vanish into a week's production. It does not vanish into twenty. So the plant that means this work has a different binder, or a different setting of mind: short batches, a cover printer that can match a colour we have already approved, a text printer that is allowed to run a handful without being accused of idleness. The idleness is the point. You wait. If you print ahead to feel busy, you have rebuilt the warehouse in a smaller size and called it efficiency.
The fight about the copy
The price conversation happens after they have seen a copy and liked it, which is the cruellest timing. They like the book. They do not like the unit cost beside the spreadsheet from the long printing.
I put the two costs on the table without a currency sign, because the argument is about what is inside each number, not about a figure I would be inventing if I named one. In the old number: paper, print, binding, a long makeready spread thin, a publisher's guess at quantity. Out of the old number: storage, returns, pulping, the cash that sat in unsold books, the reprint we did in a panic when the guess was low. In the new number: the file check, the cover match, the binding of a short batch, the fact that the press does not get a long run to dilute its start, the standing readiness to make more next week without a new negotiation. In the new number there is no bay. That absence is the product. It is also why the copy looks expensive next to a ghost.
Some of them hear it. They have paid for pulping. They have paid for a reprint of a book that then sat down. Those publishers start to talk about the cost of having the title available, not the cost of a copy in isolation. The relationship can live there. We agree a way of working. The file is checked once, and we recheck it when they change it. The cover is approved on our paper, under our light, and that approved copy is the standard, not the offset edition from a different bulk. Small orders batch to a rhythm we both know, so we are not starting the binder for a single copy every afternoon unless the single copy is truly the order. The unit cost is allowed to be the cost of that system. It is not allowed to be dressed up as the old thousand with the zeros removed.
Others don't hear it. They ask us to "sharpen" the copy cost until it resembles the long-run memory. The only ways to do that are ways that put the stock problem back on this floor. Print a quiet pile and hope the trickle catches up. Use a cheaper paper that makes the spine wrong and the colour a cousin of the edition. Skip the file check and discover the missing heading in a bookshop. I have tried, earlier in this shift of the trade, to be helpful in those ways. The helpfulness produced a small warehouse and a complaint. I don't do it now. If the comparison is the only conversation they want, they still have the option of a long printing and a bay. We can quote that. We can even mean it, for a title they truly know will sell through. Print on demand is not a moral duty. It is a choice about who holds the unsold book. If they want the old price, they can have the old risk.
What this plant had to become
The presses changed because the order changed, not because a brochure told us to. A long-run book press earns its place on the titles that are still a real printing: a frontlist book with a number the publisher will stand behind, a school book that is actually adopted, a run where the paper and the binding are specified and the quantity will absorb the start. We still do that work. It would be a lie to say the trickle has replaced it. Some books are a pallet, and a pallet is a sane way to make them.
The other half of the building is the half their Tuesday file was asking for. Text on a digital press we have qualified for the papers we are willing to keep. Covers on a machine that can hit a colour twice, months apart, because the trickle will test your memory. A binding line that is happy to start. People whose job is the file, not the pallet. A storage system that is folders and proofs, not bays and shrink wrap. Invoices that are small and frequent, which the accounting clerk hated until we admitted that the alternative was a large invoice and a bay full of doubt.
The cash feels different, and anyone who tells you otherwise has not collected it. A long printing is a large bill and a large risk that the bill is argued later. A trickle is a series of small bills, each one tied to copies that left. The small bills are healthier and they are easier to resent, because each one shows the unit cost without a pile to soften it. I would rather be resented for a visible cost than liked for a hidden bay.
There is a limit to how far I will let the promise stretch. We will hold a file we have checked. We will not hold a hundred files that were never opened, on the hope that orders might come, while the publishers treat us as a free warehouse of possibilities. Readiness has a cost. If a title goes quiet for long enough, we say so, and we agree whether it is still a live promise or a file we are keeping out of politeness. Politeness is how the stock problem sneaks back, this time as unpaid attention.
The publisher's production manager came to see the first copies of that novel. She put one next to the shop edition. The spine was the argument, as I had told her it would be, and we had built the cover to the bulk we were actually printing, so the argument ended in the hand. She asked whether we could get the cost "closer to before". I showed her the empty space in the bay where the last title had finally gone. That space is the cheaper part of the new arrangement. The copy in her hand is the dearer part. Together they are the deal. A file, a trickle, and a unit cost that includes the readiness the warehouse used to fake. If she wants the old number back, the bay is still there. I would rather she didn't fill it.