Why print mergers keep happening

# Why print mergers keep happening The first signing I sat through was in a label plant that smelled of solvent and of the lunch somebody had eaten at the press. Two owners, one table, a rewind running in the next room because nobody was going to stop a customer's reels for a lawyer. I

Why print mergers keep happening

The first signing I sat through was in a label plant that smelled of solvent and of the lunch somebody had eaten at the press. Two owners, one table, a rewind running in the next room because nobody was going to stop a customer's reels for a lawyer. I was there for the seller, who wanted to know whether the buyer was purchasing a business or purchasing a story. The second signing, a season later, was in a commercial sheetfed group, and the lunch was better and the reason was worse. Print mergers keep happening. The ones that deserve to happen are about plant load, a route to a buyer, and finishing you don't have. The ones that only buy turnover still happen, because turnover is easy to put in a sentence and load is not.

They call it synergy on the first slide, and the word flatters everyone. On the floor it explains nothing. A press does not become busier because two logos shared a photograph. A buyer does not move his work because a letterhead got longer. If you cannot point at a machine that will be fuller, a door to a customer that was shut, or a finishing line that stops a job leaving the building, you are watching money change hands. You are not watching a plant get better.

The label deal that had a shape

The seller ran a narrow-web plant with tired presses and a customer list that would make a larger converter hungry. Food, a slice of pharma, a few household brands who had been with him since the presses were new. His audits were current. His people knew how to talk to a filler who stops a line because a label is wrong. What he did not have was press time he trusted. The older machines missed too many days. He was turning work away, or taking it and subcontracting the printing while he did the finishing, which is a painful way to keep a customer. He also had a finishing habit the buyer lacked. Booklet labels. A varnish the buyer's line didn't lay. An inspection system his quality manager actually used, rather than a camera bought for a tour.

The buyer was a larger label group with newer presses and a gap where those customers should have been. Their sales people could get a meeting. They could not get the approval. The filler's technical team wanted a plant that had already survived an audit of the kind the seller passed as a matter of routine. The buyer's presses, meanwhile, had open hours. Not a rumour of open hours. A schedule I was allowed to see, with gaps where a campaign had shortened and a prospect had stalled. They were sending some complex labels out to finish, and they were tired of explaining the delay.

Put those two facts on one page and the deal has a shape before anyone mentions price. The seller's customers can move onto the buyer's better presses without being asked to trust a stranger's quality system, because the seller's quality people come too. The buyer's open hours stop being open. The finishing stays in the combined plant instead of leaving in a van. The route to the filler, which was the seller's real asset, gets a press that can answer the phone on a bad week. I walked the two halls before I was willing to say that. The buyer's press minders were under-used and good. The seller's finishing crew were busy and specific. Nobody needed a speech. The reels told it.

The hard part was not the romance of the combination. The hard part was the customers who had chosen the seller because he was small. A few of them will leave when the name on the delivery note changes, and a buyer who has not planned for that will discover that a route is a relationship, not a file in a drawer. We wrote that down. We also wrote down which presses would actually be turned off. The seller's oldest machine was not a heritage item. It was a source of missed dates. Keeping it "just in case" would have preserved a toy and diluted the load that made the deal sensible. The merger works if the work moves onto the presses that deserve it, and if the finishing the buyer lacked is still in the building the morning after completion. If those two moves don't happen, the shape was a slide.

I asked the seller, after the signing, what he had sold. He said the customers and the booklet line, and he said the presses were what the buyer thought they were buying. He was right about the customers. He was righter than the buyer about the presses. A tired press is not an asset just because it is on the asset list. The asset was the door to the filler, the audits that kept the door open, and a finishing line that stopped the job being a reel of plain print. Load, route, finishing. In that order, on that floor.

What had to be true afterwards

A sensible deal can still be wrecked in the first year, so I stayed interested. The test I told both of them to use was dull. Six months on, is the buyer's previously quiet press actually running the seller's reels? Are the booklet jobs still finished in-house, by the people who knew them? Has a filler called the new plant at an awkward hour and got a person who understands the line? If the answers are yes, the merger did the thing. If the reels are still being printed on the old iron because "the customer likes the old place", then you have bought a second factory and a set of feelings.

There is a labour question they both dodged in the room and could not dodge on the Monday. Two production managers. Two ways of naming a reel. A quality file that lives in different folders. None of that is a reason to avoid the deal. It is a reason to decide, before the photograph, which system is the system. The seller's audit habit had to survive contact with the buyer's larger and sloppier confidence. The buyer's press discipline had to survive contact with the seller's habit of saying yes to a short run the old presses could just about do. I have seen a good shape undone by a polite refusal to choose. Everyone keeps their method. The customer meets both methods in one delivery, and the delivery is late.

The price, which I am not going to quote, was argued in the usual way. What I cared about was whether the price assumed the customers would stay and the open hours would fill. If you pay for a route and then frighten the route, you have paid for turnover you will not keep. The seller's loyalty was personal. The buyer had to keep the people the fillers already asked for by name, at least through the approvals. A press can be replaced more easily than an approval. That is an unglamorous sentence, and it is the one that decides whether a label merger was about the plant or about the announcement.

The commercial deal that bought a second hall

The second signing felt, in the room, more impressive. A commercial group bought another commercial group. Both had B1 sheetfed presses. Both had binders. Both served the same kinds of buyers in overlapping cities: reports, brochures, a thinning catalogue or two, the occasional fast job. The presentation said the combination would be stronger. Stronger at what, I asked, and the answer came back as scale. Scale of what, I asked. Turnover, in the end. The number you get by adding two numbers.

I walked both halls, because I will not take a merger on a slide even when it isn't my money. They were the same kind of hall. Similar presses, similar ages, similar quietness on the days that used to be full. The binders both had a perfect binder and a stitcher, both a bit hungry. The estimators in both places were chasing the same sort of enquiry, and in two cases, the same enquiry. Putting them together does not create a long run. It creates two plants able to disappoint the same buyer. Unless you close capacity, or you point one plant at a kind of work the other cannot do, you have purchased a duplicate.

The buyer of the group did not want to close a hall. Closing a hall is how you make a merger real, and it is also how you make enemies in a town. So the plan, such as it was, was to "fill both". Fill them with what? The long repeatable commercial work that used to fill one of them is thinner now. Buying a second helping of the same hunger does not feed anyone. Their sales forces called on the same agencies. Their papers came from the same merchants. Their finishing was not a missing capability. It was a mirrored one. There was no route they gained except the route to each other's customers, and those customers were already free to move if the price was right. You don't need a merger for that. You need a quote.

I sat with their combined order book after the deal, once the congratulations had cooled, and I marked the work that could only have been done by the acquired plant. There was some. A couple of customers who loved a particular minder. A finishing quirk. A same-day habit in one city that the other city didn't have to offer because of the road. It was not nothing. It was nowhere near a reason to own two of every machine. The rest was turnover. It looked handsome in the first announcement. It looks, on a Tuesday, like rent, wages, and a press waiting for a brochure that three other plants are also waiting for.

They have started, belatedly, to talk about specialising one hall. One site for the fast, short, versioned work. One site for the longer sheets and the binding. That conversation could have been the deal. Held after the deal, it is a repair. People have been promised that nothing will change, which is the most expensive promise in a merger, because if nothing changes you have bought a parallel business and you will run it in parallel until the cash objects. Load does not appear because you wish both halls to stay open. Load appears because the market still has that much work, or because you found work you couldn't reach before. They hadn't.

Turnover is not a press

I keep the two signings in my head when someone asks me why print companies keep buying each other. They keep buying each other because the alternative, for a lot of owners, is a slow thinning, and a buyer with money would rather purchase a book of customers than build one. Sometimes that purchase is a plant decision. The label deal was. Open hours met a route that had been closed. Finishing that had been subcontracted came back inside the wall. The tired presses were the least interesting thing in the building, and the deal was sane to the extent that everyone knew it.

Sometimes the purchase is an arithmetic decision. Add the sales. Announce a larger printer. Discover, in the first winter, that you have two of a machine the market only wants once, and a pair of estimating offices teaching each other to cut the price. That deal buys turnover. It does not buy a fuller press. It does not buy a customer you couldn't already try to win. It does not buy a finishing line you lacked. It buys a number, and the number starts to decay the moment a shared customer realises he is bidding you against yourself.

If you are the owner thinking of selling, the useful question is which of those deals you are in. A buyer who comes for your approvals, your fillers, and your finishing will ask to walk the line and will talk about which presses survive. A buyer who comes for your turnover will talk about the announcement and will be vague about the Monday. If you are the one buying, the same test runs in reverse. Point at the load. Point at the route. Point at the finishing. If your finger ends up on a revenue line and a hope that two sales teams will somehow hunt better together, you are about to own a second hall that sounds like the first. Print has enough of those already. The mergers that should keep happening are the ones a minder could explain without the slide.

Written by

Ruth Keller

Quality

Reads the sheet, the barcode and the proof, and says what she will not sign.

Related articles

Industry

Buyers want shorter dates and clearer proof

# Buyers want shorter dates and clearer proof Her email had three questions and a date that had moved in by a week. Could we deliver sooner. Could she see where...

Industry

Recycled consumables and taking them back

# Recycled consumables and taking them back The form asked if we take material back. Plates, blankets, ink tins, solvent, cores. Sales had already ticked yes, b...