Short runs are rewriting the economics of print

# Short runs are rewriting the economics of print The ticket said a few thousand. The old ticket, still clipped in the job bag, said a few hundred thousand. Same customer, same brochure, same finished size, a paper that had once been a full bay and was now a short pallet we would have to

Short runs are rewriting the economics of print

The ticket said a few thousand. The old ticket, still clipped in the job bag, said a few hundred thousand. Same customer, same brochure, same finished size, a paper that had once been a full bay and was now a short pallet we would have to order in. I had the bag open on the estimating bench because the salesperson wanted a price "in the spirit of last time". Last time the spirit was a long run. The fixed part of the job had somewhere to hide. On a few thousand sheets it has nowhere to hide, and if I hide it anyway I am not estimating. I am hoping.

I have priced this brochure in both its lives. The long life was a pleasure in a grim way. You checked the file, you made plates, you lost a lift of sheets at the start, you ran, and the cost of all that preparation sat as a thin skin on a large pile. The customer never asked about the skin. He asked about the price per thousand, and the price per thousand looked sane because the thousand was not carrying the morning. The short life is the same tasks and a pile you can see the end of while you are still making ready. Everything we used to spread is still there. The run has stopped offering its back.

What the long run was hiding

People talk about short runs as if the press had become greedier. The press is the same machine. The arithmetic around it is what changed.

Selling time doesn't shrink because the quantity shrank. Somebody still visited, or still wrote the quote, or still sat in a call while three people at the customer disagreed about a headline. The proof still has to be made and looked at. If they change the headline, the proof happens again. A long run could absorb a second proof without anyone writing it down. A few thousand cannot absorb it unless I decide, in the price, that they will.

Prepress doesn't shrink to fit. The file is checked or it isn't. An imposition is built or it isn't. A picture that is heavy on the ink is heavy whether you print it all week or all morning. On the long run that checking was a small door into a large room. On the short run the door is the room.

Plates don't care about the quantity. A set of plates for this brochure costs what a set of plates costs. I am not going to put a currency on it. I am going to say that the set is the same set we hung when the job was a few hundred thousand, and the invoice from the plate line does not arrive with a discount for sympathy. If the job is four colours, it is four plates, or eight if it perfects, and a remake is another set. The long run made a remake a bruise. The short run makes a remake the whole margin, and sometimes the whole sense of having taken the job.

Makeready and the waste at the start are the part the minder feels. You still have to get the colour up. You still have to get the fit. You still spoil sheets before the sheet you can sell, and the number of those sheets is about the difficulty of the job, not about the number you were asked to deliver. On a long run those spoiled sheets disappear into the pile, and how large a share they are changes with the job. On a short run those same sheets can be a visible slice of the pallet. The customer sees them if he walks the delivery. He does not see them in the old price per thousand, which is why the old price per thousand has become a trap.

Then there is the wash-up if the colour before this one was a different kind of job, and the admin that pretends to be free. A delivery note. An invoice. A call when one carton of the brochure is short. A salesperson's apology if the paper we ordered in is a day late. A long run paid those calls easily. A short run pays them by taking money from the printing itself. The estimator who only looks at impressions is looking at the part of the job that got cheaper to talk about and more expensive to inhabit.

The estimate has to show the fixed part

The salesperson wanted one number, a per-thousand, in the spirit of last time. I gave him two numbers and I refused to let him divide one by the other and email the result.

The first number is the cost of getting to the first saleable sheet. File, proof, plates, makeready, the waste we expect on a job of this difficulty, the wash-up if the schedule can't avoid it. That number barely moves if he comes back and asks for a few more cartons. The second number is the running cost of the sheets once the press is in colour. That number does move with quantity. Put them in one blended price and the buyer compares it with a memory. The memory wins, and then everyone is angry. Show them separately and the buyer can see why a few thousand is not a shrunken long run. Some buyers will still go elsewhere. Good. Elsewhere can discover the same arithmetic, or elsewhere is a digital press where the arithmetic is honestly different.

I have changed the form we quote on. The makeready is a line. The plates are a line. The proof is a line. The running is a line. It looks fussy. It stops a conversation in which a buyer says "but last time it was..." and a salesperson finishes the sentence with a discount. Last time it was a different job, and the form has to be rude enough to say so.

Gang running is the other temptation, and sometimes it is real. If I have three short jobs on the same paper, the same colours, the same kind of coverage, and they can share a makeready without sharing a delivery disaster, then the fixed part has found a new back to hide on. I will gang those. I will not gang a customer's brochure with a stranger's leaflet because both are four colours and both are short. The stranger's reprint, the customer's late correction, the two delivery addresses, the fact that one of them is a special red and the other isn't: that is how a gang becomes two makereadies wearing one costume. The estimate has to say which jobs are truly sharing the start, and what happens to the price if one of them drops out. A gang that cannot survive one dropout was never a saving. It was a hope stacked on the sheet.

Digital is the other honest door, and I use it when the fixed part of offset is the thing the customer is refusing to see. A few thousand of a simple brochure, text and pictures, a paper we have qualified on the digital press, no special colour, no coating the toner can't stand in for. There the plates leave the conversation. The makeready leaves in the old sense. A different cost arrives, the cost of the digital sheet, and it does not pretend to get dramatically kinder if he suddenly wants a few hundred thousand. I tell him that too. Short-run economics are not a moral victory for digital. They are a point where one process stops being able to hide its preparation, and another process has less preparation to hide. If the run grows back to a few hundred thousand and the file settles, the work can come back to the cylinder, and the estimate should be willing to say so without sulking.

There is also the question of the paper. Ordering a special grade for a few thousand is a way of adding freight, a minimum making, and a leftover reel or pallet to a job that cannot carry them. I price the paper we have on the floor as one thing, and the paper we must bring in as another. If the leftover cannot be used, it is part of this job, not a romantic stock holding. The long run used to leave us with a usable remnant. The short run leaves us with a remnant that is the size of the job. I would rather change his paper, with his eyes open, than own a pallet of a grade nobody else buys.

What the press day becomes

The minder on the five-colour learned the new economics before the sales floor did. His day used to be one or two jobs, a long settle, a long hold. His day now, on the commercial work, is a string of makereadies. He gets to colour, he runs a quantity he could almost carry, and he comes off. The skill has shifted under his feet. Holding a colour for a day is still a skill, and we still need it on the work that remains long. Getting to an acceptable colour quickly, on a job that will be over before lunch, is the skill the short ticket asks for. They are not the same temperament. A man who will chase a highlight for an hour because the long run will repay him is a man who will sink a short job. A man who lets a short job go out "close enough" will be punished the day the short job is a brand colour with a buyer standing there.

I have had to say this in the roster, not just in the estimate. The short-run day needs a plan that respects wash-ups. If I sequence a special colour between two process jobs, I have created a wash-up that the quantity cannot pay. If I group the process work, and I put the specials together with their eyes open, the press spends more of its day in saleable sheets. That is not a heroic efficiency programme. It is a refusal to let the schedule add fixed costs the estimator then has to invent a discount to cover.

We also had to stop treating every short job as a visitor from the long-run world in its standards. The pass sheet still matters. The fit still matters. What we stopped doing is the open-ended chase. On a few thousand, there is a point where another half hour of adjustment costs more than the customer will ever be asked to pay, and the sheet is already inside the tolerance we agreed. I write the tolerance down before the press starts, in words a minder and a buyer can both see. "Match the proof on this paper under this light. Do not open a new argument about last year's brochure." Last year's brochure was a few hundred thousand on a different making of paper. It is not the standard for this ticket unless we have agreed to be paid for that chase.

The salesperson did, in the end, send the two-part price. The buyer rang me, which I prefer. He said the running looked fair and the getting-started looked like a penalty. I told him it was the part he had been paying all along, hidden inside a quantity he no longer orders. He could have the long-run price per thousand on a long-run quantity, and he could have it tomorrow if he wanted the warehouse back. He didn't. He wanted a few thousand, fresh, and he wanted them to cost like a slice of the old pile. They don't. They cost like a job that has to be started.

He placed it. He placed it with the makeready visible, and with a paper we had, which meant I had talked him out of the grade on the old ticket. The minder ran it in the middle of a sequence of process-colour work, so the wash-up didn't land on it. The plates were one set. No remake. That is the short-run job when the estimating and the press are telling the same story. It is not a cheap job. It is a legible one. The long run used to make sloppy pricing look clever. A few thousand make it obvious, which is a gift if you are willing to show the fixed part, and a threat if your whole habit is to divide by a number that isn't there any more.

Written by

Daniel Okonkwo

Works office

Turns an enquiry into a job bag, and a finished pile into a delivery.

Related articles

Industry

Buyers want shorter dates and clearer proof

# Buyers want shorter dates and clearer proof Her email had three questions and a date that had moved in by a week. Could we deliver sooner. Could she see where...

Industry

Recycled consumables and taking them back

# Recycled consumables and taking them back The form asked if we take material back. Plates, blankets, ink tins, solvent, cores. Sales had already ticked yes, b...