Global print capacity is being reallocated

# Global print capacity is being reallocated The schedule on the wall had the eight-colour in red and the digital press in pencil. Red meant a minder, a crew, a promise. Pencil meant the jobs nobody had wanted to admit were the week. I was in a sheetfed plant on the edge of a city

Global print capacity is being reallocated

The schedule on the wall had the eight-colour in red and the digital press in pencil. Red meant a minder, a crew, a promise. Pencil meant the jobs nobody had wanted to admit were the week. I was in a sheetfed plant on the edge of a city that used to live on commercial work, and the owner had asked me over because he was about to sign for another press. He thought the building was short of iron. The building was short of honesty about which iron the orders still wanted.

I had been in a second plant the day before, a day's travel away, where the noise was different. There the new machine was an inkjet line, and the queue was versions of a retail file, each one a region, each one short of the length that makes a plate feel cheap. The two plants buy paper from some of the same merchants. They do not have the same future, and they are not short of the same thing. That is the reallocation. It does not arrive as a headline in the office. It arrives as a red mark on a board and a pencil mark nobody priced properly.

What still belongs on offset

I asked the minder on the eight-colour what he had that he would fight to keep. He didn't talk about the industry. He talked about the job on the feed board. A carton for a brand that cares about a red. The red is a special. The board is heavy enough that the sheet sounds different when it hits the front lays. There is a coating to lay while the sheet is still in the machine. The run is long enough that the plates, the wash-up, and the pile of sheets at the start are a beginning, not the bill.

That work stays. I don't need a theory for it. The colour has to match a delivery from last season, and the buyer will stand at the press and look. A digital press in the next bay can make a picture. It cannot make this picture on this board, in this red, at this length, without turning the job into an argument about whether close is the brand. Close is not the brand. The cylinder is the right tool, and a plant that keeps a crew who can hold that colour is holding the part of the trade that has not moved.

The same logic sits on a different machine in a different country, and I had seen it the week before on a heatset web that still prints a weekly. One edition, one paper, a run that fills the press and gives the folder something to do. The owner of that web is not confused. He knows the weekly is the reason the oven is lit. He has not tried to pretend the web is a general answer for every file that arrives. Offset, sheet or web, still earns where the job is stable. Same file. Same stock. Enough copies that makeready is a start. A special colour, a coating, a weight of board or a weight of paper the digital line handles as a favour. A brand that will compare this delivery with the last one and be right to.

What has walked off the cylinder

The pencil jobs were the walk. I took three of them out of the rack. The first was a catalogue in three versions. The pictures were cousins. The prices were not, and the store list on the back was not, and the legal line in one version had been rewritten the afternoon before. Somebody had planned it as offset. The plates would have been made, hung, and made again. The second was a run of covers, same size, different city on each. The third was a set of invitations. Lovely paper. Almost no two names the same. The estimator had a plate cost sitting on the invitations because the template in his system starts with a plate.

This is the work that moves. It moves because the file will not sit still, or because the run is too short to carry plates and a wash-up and a minder's morning, or because the customer has learned that a change is allowed. Once a customer has sent a correction on the morning of the run and been told yes, he will send another. Offset can say yes. It says yes with a new plate and a new makeready. Digital says yes with a new file. The customer can feel the difference in the bill, and if he can't, his procurement people can.

The owner said the catalogue used to be one file and a long run, and the plant had been built around that sentence. The retail group had not cancelled print. They had broken it. A version per region. A cover that changes. A print run that looks, on a single version, like a short job, and looks, across the year, like a relationship. The relationship left his eight-colour because his eight-colour was the wrong door for a file that changes. It did not leave print. I had seen the same kind of retail work queued on the inkjet a day's travel away. Different plant. Different country. The press that grew was not the press that used to have the logo on the delivery notes.

Some of the walking work is not even versioned. It is simply shorter. A brochure that was a week's printing is an afternoon, and an afternoon on a big sheetfed is a bad afternoon. The crew is sized for a long run. The wash-up is sized for a long run. The pricing is a memory of a long run. The customer can get the afternoon elsewhere, on a press that was bought for afternoons. So the capacity grows in the plants that admitted the afternoon, and it sits idle, or it sits badly used, in the plants that are still dressed for the week.

How a plant keeps the wrong machine

The wrong machine is usually a machine that was right. I have stopped treating the purchase as the mistake. The mistake is the year after the orders change, when the depreciation is still true and the order book is not, and everybody is too loyal to the iron to say so.

In the city plant the eight-colour is a good press. It is the wrong press for the pencil jobs, and the pencil jobs are a large part of what sales can actually find. They keep putting those jobs on it for three reasons, and none of them is technical. The crew is employed on it. The estimator's system starts with plates, so the quote looks like a proper quote. And the digital press is still spoken of as the small machine, even though the small machine is the one with the queue that matches the market they have. Loyalty to a press is a human thing. It becomes a capacity error when the loyalty decides the schedule. The digital operator already knows the edge of her machine. She can take a file change without a plate, and she cannot do the special red on the heavy board. A plant gets the wrong machine partly by refusing to hear that.

The owner of the inkjet plant had made the other error first, and he told me about it without being asked. He had bought the inkjet because a salesman said the future was digital, and he had tried to put his long carton work on it. The cartons hated it. The red was an argument. The board was a compromise. The run length made the inkjet a dear way to lay a flat colour. He nearly decided inkjet was a lie. Then he moved the cartons back to the cylinder, where they had always belonged, and he let the inkjet have the versions. The machine stopped being wrong when the work on it became the work it is for. He was lucky. He had both machines. A plant that has only the fashionable one, and a book of work that still wants offset, is in the same ditch as the plant that has only the eight-colour and a book of versions.

Hybrid is the word that gets used when a plant wants to avoid the ditch without choosing. Sometimes the word is accurate. I have seen a sheetfed with an inkjet unit over the delivery, laying a code, a name, a price, a region, onto a shell the offset units had printed properly. The shell is stable. The changeable part is not. Each process does the part it is honest at. The job is one pass, and the crew knows which unit is allowed to be the variable one. The offset units still earn their keep on the picture and the colour. The head earns its keep on the line of type that changes. Nobody pretends the head is printing the red.

The word goes bad when it is an excuse to keep every job on the expensive iron and dab the new process on the edge. You get two makereadies and a cost that belongs to neither process cleanly. A hybrid earns its floor space when you can point at the sheet and say which marks came off the plate and which came off the head. If you cannot say that, you have bought a story.

Places, not a single industry

Offset iron is still being justified beside fillers, beside long stable work, beside a brand that looks at a special colour and means it. Digital iron is being added where the file will not sit still. A packaging hall near a filler can be short of a press while a commercial hall a few hours away is trying to invent work for a press it already has. Moving the carton across that gap to "use the capacity" feels thrifty in a meeting. On the dock it means board travelling twice, a colour standard living in the wrong building, and a filler who wanted the converter close. The capacity was never spare in the way the spreadsheet said. It was spare for leaflets. The filler did not order a leaflet.

The owner in the city plant walked me back to the wall. He wanted a recommendation he could take to the bank. I would not give him a model name. I took the live jobs off the rack and I made him sort them on the meeting table. One pile stayed on the eight-colour. The carton. A long run of a leaflet that really was long. Anything where the brand would stand at the console and be right. One pile was digital, including the invitations and the regional covers, and two jobs that were already on the eight-colour out of habit. One pile was the argument: mid-length, some versions, coverage a toner press would sweat over. That middle pile is where the wrong machine gets fed. It is also where an inkjet earns if the versions are real, and where offset still earns if the versions are a salesperson's decoration on a stable job.

He asked which country to put the next press in. That was a better question than which brochure to believe. His carton work is tied to a filler a few hours away, and that work should stay near the filler, on a cylinder, in this building or in one closer. His versioned commercial work is tied to customers who send files, and files do not care which country the head is in, until the delivery promise and the customs desk do. If he buys, he buys the process the middle pile actually is, and he puts it where the jobs are allowed to stay on it. He does not buy a second eight-colour to keep the red mark on the board looking like the plant he remembers.

The board has to tell the truth

I left the piles on the table. A month of honest sorting will tell him more than I can. If the middle pile is versions and it keeps arriving, the next machine is not a bigger sheetfed. If the middle pile is a memory of the old catalogue and the carton is the business, the next spend might be a crew, or a finishing line, or the willingness to send short commercial work to a plant that wants it. Capacity is being reallocated because buyers changed the shape of the order, and because they changed the place they want the pack printed. A plant ends up with the wrong machine when it keeps staffing, pricing, and praising the orders it used to have.

The eight-colour was back in production when I went down. The red looked right. The digital press was on a cover for a city that had not been in the job yesterday. Both machines were earning because someone had put the right job on each. The owner can sign for a press when he can say which pile it is for and which place it has to stand. Until then the iron he already owns is trying to be two plants, and it is doing one of them badly.

Written by

Helen Ward

Sheetfed printer

Runs sheetfed offset and writes up the job that went wrong on her press.

Related articles

Industry

Buyers want shorter dates and clearer proof

# Buyers want shorter dates and clearer proof Her email had three questions and a date that had moved in by a week. Could we deliver sooner. Could she see where...

Industry

Recycled consumables and taking them back

# Recycled consumables and taking them back The form asked if we take material back. Plates, blankets, ink tins, solvent, cores. Sales had already ticked yes, b...